10-14-2016, 04:30 PM
Thanks for taking the time (again) to do this Shake. I think we all can appreciate the effort.
And fwiw, I think the scoring is about as fair as you're going to get. Any system like this is always going to have something someone can latch on to to complain about it. Grading coaches isn't an exact science. I think the real issue lies with posters who are hell bent on having an argument than actually having a discussion about the overall value of this system. There's plenty of meat in this topic, plenty of ways to look at it. I think if someone immediately looks for flaws then that says more about having an agenda than anything else.
And fwiw, I think the scoring is about as fair as you're going to get. Any system like this is always going to have something someone can latch on to to complain about it. Grading coaches isn't an exact science. I think the real issue lies with posters who are hell bent on having an argument than actually having a discussion about the overall value of this system. There's plenty of meat in this topic, plenty of ways to look at it. I think if someone immediately looks for flaws then that says more about having an agenda than anything else.
