Latest Bengals Mail (Coley Harvey)

[*bfine32*]

(05-26-2015, 01:27 PM)RoyleRedlegs Wrote: It's not making it up. He rarely had to "make throws"
His throws were canned easy throws. It involved a ton of easy completions and beating people up with his running game.

As for the NC game in 13, they ran 45 times. Eddie Lacy had 145 on the ground and Yeldon had 101. All the passing TDs were was play selection. If you watched that game, the run game and the run defense was why they won. They brutalized ND up front on both sides.

Why is winning so much more important in evaluating McCarron? Why aren't people focusing on the actual QB things? Reading defenses, footwork, arm strength, pocket presence, touch/placement....

This is just silly. AJ’s last 2 years at Bama he threw for 5,996 yards, 58 TDs, and 10 INTs while completing over 67% of his passes.

I’ve seen some folks on here try to compare him to McElroy because they went to the same school. In McElroy’s last 2 years at Bama he threw for over 500 fewer yards, 21 fewer TDs, and 1 fewer INT while completing around 65% of his passes. (Keep in mind McElroy had Julio Jones)

Hell compare his final 2 years to our own Andy Dalton. Andy threw for over 300 fewer yards, 8 fewer TDs, and 4 more INTs while completing around 63% of his passes.

Come up with something else besides all AJ did in college was hand the ball off and throw bad passes.