Phillips, Hopkins, Tate , Johnson

[CJD]

If I were to give each major contributor on this team a grade on the season it would be as follows:

Scale:
Bad: Needs replaced now.
Weak: Needs replaced, but not urgently.
Fair: Average player. Could be replaced, but not a major concern in the rebuild.
Good: Above average player. No need to replace.
Elite: Retain at all costs.

OFFENSE:

QB:
Andy Dalton: Fair
Ryan Finley: Bad

RB:
Joe Mixon: Elite
Giovani Bernard: Fair

WR:
AJ Green: Good
Auden Tate: Fair
Tyler Boyd: Good
Alex Erickson: Weak
John Ross: Fair

TE:
Tyler Eifert: Good
CJ Uzomah: Fair
Drew Sample: TBD/Weak

OT:
Jonah Williams: TBD/Good
Fred Johnson: Fair (limited snap count)
Cordy Glenn: Fair
John Jerry: Bad
Bobby Hart: Bad

OG:
Michael Jordan: Weak (with potential)
Billy Price: Bad (give him 1 more year before cutting him).
John Miller: Fair
Alex Redmond: Weak

Center:
Trey Hopkins: Good


DEFENSE:

DE:
Carlos Dunlap: Good
Sam Hubbard: Good
Carl Lawson: Good
Andrew Brown: Weak

DT:
Andrew Billings: Fair
Geno Atkins: Good
Josh Tupou: Fair
Ryan Glasgow: Fair

LB:
Germaine Pratt: Fair
Nick Vigil: Fair
Hardy Nickerson: Weak
Jordan Evans: Weak
LaRoy Reynolds: Bad

CB:
Dre Kirkpatrick: Fair
Darqueze Dennard: Good
William Jackson III: Good
Darius Phillips: Good
B.W. Webb: Bad
Tony McRae: Weak

S:
Shawn Williams: Good
Jessie Bates III: Good
Clayton Fejedelem: Fair
Brandon Wilson: Fair

ST:
Randy Bullock: Good
Kevin Huber: Good
Clark Harris: Fair
Alex Erickson: Fair
Darius Phillips: Fair
Brandon Wilson: Good

Maybe I'm being too generous, but I think we can fix this team in 2 drafts :)