Who did you like Better?

[Nicomo Cosca]

Carson looked like he was going to be an elite top 3 QB in 05, but he was just never the same after Kimo the assassin.

Dalton obviously had the better career here stats-wise, but he also had much better defenses (other than 09) and better OC’s (Jay, Hue). Palmer went against tougher AFC North defenses, too. Prime Ray Lewis Ravens, and prime Polamalu Steelers. I also think Palmer probably wins at least one of those playoff games from 2011-2014, but alas...

Unpopular opinion, especially today when folks are feeling sentimental, but I have to go with Palmer.