Ranking All NFL Teams 5-year Success by Draft Class

[Benton]

(11-22-2017, 03:25 PM)THE PISTONS Wrote: So if a guy is good but is always injured he was still a god pick? This is a where the rubber meets the road moment. They base it on actual production.

Having a Pro Bowl TE that never plays doesn't help us win any games...so no matter how you slice it his production is low.

re: Kroft - If you see the field in the NFL you're going to get atleast some numbers. Like a #2 WR on most teams will get 600-800 yards. A TE will get 400-500 yards as a starter. It's just how the ball is distributed.

To the question: No. That was always my criticism of ASmith... his inability to play at a consistently high level due to injuries (or apathy). 

Which if that's all you take out of five years of drafting — that arguably the guy with some of the most potential was often injured — then I can see where you'd be disappointed.