QB Index by Gregg Rosenthal

[Brownshoe]

(09-11-2015, 11:20 AM)djs7685 Wrote: Hah, I don't know if he's had none, but they haven't been top of the league great over his career that I remember. He's had some great players around him at times, but I don't seem to recall him having a full lineup of good players in a given year. Could be wrong though, I must say I'm not an expert on 2011-2014 Panthers history to remember their lineups each year, they all kind of jumble together in my mind


They look like "not elite but better than Andy Dalton" numbers to me. The postseason speaks for itself, and his regular seasons have been regularly solid enough outside of one year to not take his ranking down as much as you want it to.

Your obsession with Andy is honestly pretty sad.

He's had Steve Smith from 2011-2013, He's had Brandon Lafell from 2011-2013, He's had Greg Olsen from 2011-2015, He's had DeAngelo Williams from 2011-2014, and Jonathan Stewart 2011-2015, and Benjamin for 2014. He's had solid weapons. Williams and Stewart are better than people like BJGE.