Message Board All-Time Bengal Team (QB)

[*Nately120*]

Call me a hater, but I don't think "Dalton might win a Super Bowl" and "Dalton threw 4 more TD passes in the era where you aren't allowed to give a WR a dirty look" is really compelling evidence that he is the best. Geez, the TD passes one...didn't Dalton throw 1 more TD pass than Palmer did in 2005? I'm not even going to get into the idea of saying Dalton is better than Kenny and Boomer because in my mind 4 straight playoff loses doesn't stack up to winning the playoffs at all much less coming within a few minutes of winning the Super Bowl.

As long as we are picking arbitrary things I'll contest that Carson Palmer is the greatest of all 4 because he made the most money being a professional QB.