Greatest Bengals RB: Dillon or Brooks?

[*ochocincos*]

My vote was for Dillon, especially going back to look at the stats.

Yes, Brooks has better yards per touch and 14 more TDs for the Bengals, but he played a year longer than Dillon with Cincy and never had more than 221 carries in a season.

Dillon, on the other hand, had more receptions and yards than I realized, was a workhorse (5 seasons with 262+ carries), and might have had more TDs than Brooks if he was the primary ball carrier in 2003 and stayed with CIN for at least 2004.

I will give Brooks a ton of credit though for being pretty reliable and producing as much as he did while only being 180 lbs.