Rank Dalton Among All QB's

[Millhouse]

(10-09-2017, 04:50 PM)THE PISTONS Wrote: I put him somewhere between 15-16.

I take these guys over him:
-Brady
-Alex Smith (11 TD 0 Int this year)
-Rodgers
-Brees
-Carr
-Cousins
-Newton
-Wentz
-Goff
-Stafford
-Dak Prescott
-Winston
-Russell Wilson
-Matt Ryan
-Roethlisberger (had 1 bad game but you'd still take him over Dalton.)

I think he falls into this list somewhere depending on preference. I think I'd take Watson over him...but not Manning and maybe Rivers.

-Eli Manning
-Rivers
-Watson

Here's the full list:
http://www.nfl.com/stats/categorystats?d-447263-n=1&d-447263-o=2&d-447263-p=1&statisticCategory=PASSING&d-447263-s=PASSING_PASSER_RATING

I take these guys over him as well:

- Brady
- Alex Smith (MVP currently, but playing on a better overall team)
- Rodgers 
- Brees  
- Carr
- Newton
- Wentz
- Goff
- Stafford
- Winston
- Russell Wilson (his playoff & Super Bowl history is the tiebreaker. Sue me, I like winners in the big games)
- Matt Ryan
- Roethlisberger 


- Dak Prescott (similar to Watsons reason)
- Watson  (only if I was starting over after blowing everything up, and keeping AJ for him)

Then...

- Cousins (flip flop, but give him AJ Green then who knows)
- Eli Manning (too old but & not nearly as good as Brees & Brady, but few years ago yes)
- Rivers (same reason as Manning)
- Luck (his injuries are mainly the reason he is here. He is definitely the better talent tho when fully healthy and on a competent team. Plus he has never had an AJ Green caliber receiver like some of those quarterbacks listed above have had for their entire careers)