The QB position

[fredtoast]

(05-10-2018, 07:41 AM)CornerBlitz Wrote: Since you guys hate the QBR because it makes Andy Dalton look bad I decided to go with QB rating. Again he was average to below average every season with the exception of 2015 the last 5 seasons.

2013-15th
2014-25th
2015-2nd 12 games only
2016-17th
2017-17th

I am coming up with slightly different ratings, and I don't know why you don't include his entire career.

'11....20th
'12....13th
'13....15th
'14....25th
'15..... 2nd
'16.....15th
'17.....18th

So top half of the league 4 of 7 years with one elite season.  That is above average.  Without the #2 ranking in '15 you could call him just average, but no matter how much you want to, you can't make '15 disappear.  So he is an above average QB.

You talk about others ignoring facts, but you are the one trying to pretend that the 2015 season is not a "fact".

Also, "passer rating" is just one element.  As I have already pointed out Dalton is elite (top 5) in multiple catagories (Rushing Tds, Fumble Percentage, 4th Quarter Comebacks, 4th Quarter Game Winning Drives) that make him a "good" QB.