QB Index by Gregg Rosenthal

[Brownshoe]

(09-11-2015, 09:24 AM)djs7685 Wrote: Since when does a defense ranking mean that he didn't have a great game?! I'm 100% sure you don't play that way for Andy as well, do you? I'll keep that in mind in the future if you'd like.

He had 1 bad game out of the last 10 playoff games, you can try and twist and turn anyway that you'd like, but it doesn't change that fact. Boldin, Smith, Rice, Pitta, and Jones are absolutely good. Plenty of elite QBs have had good teams around them, but it doesn't make them less elite. I don't know what that should change with Flacco having other good players around him. He's good too. I'd argue that our 2013 weapons and 2015 weapons are equal to or better than what you listed, but it doesn't matter either way because Joe is still more deserving of a high spot than Andy.

I don't know why you're still arguing this. Joe Flacco deserves to be higher on a QB ranking list than Andy Dalton right now. There's no reason to keep this going. It isn't debatable. Joe > Andy right now with what they've done in their respective careers. If Andy had Joe's resume you'd be happier than a pig in shit being able to rub his playoff performances in everyone's face, and don't even act like you wouldn't.

The only bad defense Dalton has played in the playoffs has been the Colts, but when you have the weapons that he had it really doesn't matter. The Chargers were 11th in points allowed in 2013, The Texans were a top 10 defense in 2012, and were ranked 2nd in points allowed in 2011.

I would say Boldin, Smith, Rice, Pitta, and Jones are better weapons than what we had in 2013, and arguably better than what we have now.