QB Index by Gregg Rosenthal

[djs7685]

(09-11-2015, 11:57 AM)WhoDeyWho Wrote: "Clearly", which is why when you add all his numbers up over his career they are lower than Dalton's.  "Clearly" he's been a better playoff QB than Dalton has.  However, the playoffs are only a fraction of a player's career.  It's as if with QBs the only games that seem to matter as far as actual QB talent is playoff games.  If that's the case, just rank players by playoff performances and call it a day.    

But that's not the case at all, you're just making shit up to be your usual condescending self.

I could completely understand your point if Flacco has been putting up 70 passer ratings every year of his career in the regular season and then lighting it up like he has in the playoffs. Then I'd be in agreement with everything you're saying. His regular seasons haven't been BAD though.

Joe Flacco - mediocre to solid regular seasons (1 good and 1 bad mixed in) and amazing playoff performances

Andy Dalton - mediocre to solid regular seasons (1 good mixed in) and bad playoff performances

I mean, just look at it that way. It's not a slight against Andy, Joe deserves to be ranked higher than a lot of guys because he turns it up a notch in the playoffs for whatever reason. He's good enough in the regular season and REALLY good in the playoffs. I hate the guy, but it is what it is man.