QB Index by Gregg Rosenthal

[djs7685]

(10-16-2015, 12:15 PM)jj22 Wrote: What qb in football history went from bottom 10 to top 5 in 5 years.... lets start with that? I'll wait. FYI, most bottom 10 qb's are out of the league or backups after 5 years. But I'll wait. And while your at it, what below average/average qb has never had a losing season? Given that only 4 teams have made the playoffs in consecutive years since 2011, and none of them have qb's deemed as below average/average. I think we both know the answer. Well I know the answer, others are still trying to make excuses for their poor qb assessments.

1. Players don't win games, lose games, make the playoffs, or miss the playoffs. Those are all team things. Andy didn't lose the playoff games, but he played a big role in at least 2 of the losses. Andy didn't win 40+ games in the regular season, but he played a big role in winning a lot of them. Agree or disagree with that assessment??

2. I don't believe Andy is, or ever was below average, so all of your below average talk doesn't apply to my thoughts and assessment.

While "your" at it, maybe you shouldn't put words in others mouths and shit talk them like "your" superior when that person wasn't even making those arguments. I won't hold my breath, because you'll never stop doing that.