PFF Grades for Seattle Game

[*bfine32*]

(09-11-2019, 12:33 PM)McC Wrote: Really bad comparison.  The BS fumble actually happened in real life but your scenario only happened in your head because, for all we know, he might have times his jump perfectly and still missed the ball.

How many passes in the NFL come within a whisker of not being completed?  Half?  Maybe even more?  How much time do reasonable people spend talking about how close they came to not being completed?

See, this is the ridiculousness of having an unyielding stance.  It prevents one from seeing the entirety of the picture leads one to say some really goofy things.

The comparison is not bad; as you both are playing the "what if" game, it's just your what if is presented to make Andy's performance look better and his is to make Andy's performance look worse. IMO Andy's passer rating caught "a break" because the play was ruled a fumble; I thought it should have been an INT; not that it matters in the grand scheme