Veteran Andy > Rookie Joe Burrow

[*bfine32*]

(01-05-2020, 09:20 PM)Wes Mantooth Wrote: Here's my list of starting QB's from this year that, regardless of stats, I would've take Andy over for this past season to build a team. I'd really be curious to see who is brave enough to actually support their argument, that they ALL are currently actually better QB's.

-Kyle Allen
-Case Keenum/Dwayne Haskins
-Mitchell Trubinsky
-Jacoby Brissett
-Gardner Minshew
-Sam Darnold
-Drew Locke/Joe Flacco
-Marcus Mariotta/Ryan Tannenhill
-Daniel Jones/Eli Manning
-Mason Rudolph/Mason Hodges
-Josh Rosen/Ryan Fitzpatrick

You've got a blank slate, a new team and you get to choose one current QB for one season.  And you really are taking every single one of these guys ovee Andy Dalton?  Seriously?

Fwiw, I have Dalton somewhere mixed in with this tier. And I think I'd actually take him iver a handful of these guys...

Dalton, Rivers, Goff, Winston, Murray Mayfield, Carr, Garapolo..

For one season, that's where I'd put him... Above the first list, somewhere sandwiched in the group above.

I'm no more going to deem him worse than every single one of these names, only because of stats, then I wouldve called Joe Mixon the worst running back in the league after 8 games this year.  Why? Because I have eyes.

Let's take away the 2 that started because their starter was injured (Carolina and Pittsburg; replace them with Big Ben and Cam) and Ill pick all.