Veteran Andy > Rookie Joe Burrow

[*bfine32*]

(01-06-2020, 12:52 AM)Shake n Blake Wrote: Peep 2015 and 2019. Neither were indicative of the QB Dalton is. I guess one of us is being fair.

As to my list: Allen is the only Carolina QB to qualify (which seems important to you) this year, and who knows if Newton will be back next year? But that's just one guy on my list.

If you believe the poor state of the team had an effect on Dalton's performance (stats), why are you using his stat ranking to say he's the 32nd best QB? You don't think Dalton is better than some QB's ranked ahead of him that were in better situations?

Andy Dalton career passer rating: 87.5

Andy Dalton 2019 passer rating: 78.5 (-9.8)

Andy Dalton 2015 passer rating 106.3 (+18.8)

Yeah, they're both probably equally outliers. 

I'm saying he's the 32nd best QB because I can name 31 (or more) others I take over him. His rating just supports that.