Palmer v Burrow

[bengals67]

Interesting that this turned into a Palmer v Dalton discussion.

My intent was to compare Burrow to Palmer since Palmer was  number one and Burrow is likely to be pick number one.

Would anyone dispute that Palmer has more of the physical traits for a franchise QB than Andy?

The question is whether Palmer had the personality and confidence to be the franchise QB?

Burrow seems to have the mental qualities that Carson lacked.

Moreover, I think a case can be made that Andy is a better leader than Carson, though not as gifted physically.

If you have a chance to draft a potential Montana, or a Brady, or a Peyton or a Luck, I don't see how you can pass.

But I also expect any sane NFL organization to take  other steps to make the incubator for your possible franchise QB as strong as possible- something that I seriously doubt will be done by Mike Brown.