How about AJ McCarron

[Essex Johnson]

(01-11-2016, 06:59 PM)BigSeph Wrote: My point is that McCarron had a gutsy performance and played well in the 4th quarter.

That's all.

Some people can't bring themselves to admit the obvious, instead bashing his 4th quarter and downplaying everything he did (he only got down the field due to PI, his TD to AJ was a "floater", defense gave them great field position that's only reason they put up points, etc).

Dalton is absolutely a superior QB right now.  He should be.  He's had 4 years to work on it.

Could AJM develop?  After watching the last 4+ games, I'd say he absolutely will develop and will be a successful starting QB in the NFL for many years.  Look at the QB rating.  Look at the way the team barely lost vs. Denver and Pittsburgh.  There is a lot of promise and potential there.  That doesn't mean I want to see AJ starting for the Bengals and Andy shipped off or benched.  That doesn't mean I hate Andy.  It means I can see the progress and potential in AJM and he has grown quickly with experience.

Andy Dalton right now is a better QB to lead the Bengals.

If I said he wasn't, would it change your opinion on AJM?  Just give the guy some credit.  He deserves it.

i did give the guy credit.. no problem.. I guess the problem is when you try to compare AJM and Dalton.. you just can't.. Remember a great definition of potential  "You ain't done shit yet "... That pretty much fits AJM .. not totally since he has won in the NFL but really 4 games does not mean what will happen..  Hell if i went by that Kearns or Bruce from the Reds would have been in the Hall of Fame after the first month of their baseball careers.

So for me just don;t compare Dalton with AJM and I understand your point ... 

Dalton  solid playoff caliber NFL starter with a resume to back it up, AJM good backup with potential to be a starter in NFL.. I can buy that