(11-24-2015, 05:03 PM)BmorePat87 Wrote: Great band. I don't think Stairway is their best song, though.

agreed and agreed.

(11-25-2015, 11:05 AM)bengal_fan_in_toronto Wrote: when i started the thread i wanted to keep it to bands in the truest sense i guess.  I'm a fan of these artists mind you, but i still think most might consider them solo artists?  if we are going to include the likes of these folks then you have to put Elvis in the equation.  

I think when we look for the Best American Band.... longevity has to be in the equation. If the band was only together for say 2-3 years i cant consider it one of the best of all time. but we know some of these guys die... so if the band broke up because of a death then would have to revert to how well the songs still stand today.

Bands like the Doors , A.I.C (although still together i think but new singer) are great bands but their time cut short.

(11-23-2015, 03:40 PM)bengal_fan_in_toronto Wrote: I'm a big Skynyrd fan so naturally that's my choice 

Well it is Wednesday morning.

Do you know what that means?

Grateful Dead

Parliament/Funkadelic All Stars

(11-25-2015, 01:01 PM)fredtoast Wrote: Well it is Wednesday morning.

Do you know what that means?

it's gone in the wind?

Earth, Wind & Fire
Kool & the Gang before J.T. Taylor although they had some really good songs with him.
Frankie Beaverly & Maze
Zapp featuring Roger Troutman
Chicago was great even after they went Pop
Prince and the Revolution
Ohio Players
Isley Brothers
Parliament
Jimi Hendrix and the Expierience
Stevie Ray Vaughan and Double Trouble
Heatwave
Enchantment - this is a great group to listen to while with your woman
Lynard Skynard
Molly Hatchet
Buddy Holly and the Crickets
The Jackson 5
The Persuasions - great A'Capella Doo Wop

I guess it depends on what you're in the mood for at the time.

(11-25-2015, 01:39 PM)bengal_fan_in_toronto Wrote: it's gone in the wind?

(11-25-2015, 01:04 PM)fredtoast Wrote: Grateful Dead

Parliament/Funkadelic All Stars

The mental image I have of you listening to Parliament makes me chuckle.

My favorite song of theirs is US Custom Coast Guard Dope Dog.

YO-HO...........ROOF!!!

DOIN' IT DOGGY STYLE
U.S. Custom Coast Guard Dope Dog, nicknamed "BUST EM"
Like most dope sniffin' dogs, he's got a habit, trained to have to have it.
Pick up the tracks of the trafficker, and track em' like a rabbit up the coastline.
Canine controlled substance retriever.
Receiver of the "Golden Nose" award, for leadin' em' to the cash, cashin' in on the stash.
Now he's in line for his issue of the booty.
Never do a line in the line of duty, he's a dope dog.

Well, I did my research and apparently it is these guys:

(11-25-2015, 04:04 PM)bfine32 Wrote: Well, I did my research and apparently it is these guys:

you won the internet today sir.

I think you could make a pretty strong case for it being R.E.M..  They had longevity (formed in 1980, broke up in 2011), one line up (when drummer Bill Berry left for medical reasons in 1997 they became a trio and never replaced him), they've sold 85 million records worldwide, and are in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.  They're also influential musically (Kurt Cobain being extremely vocal about it) and critically acclaimed.  

So you've got a band that started on and indie, were very successful, signed to a major label, became even more successful, influenced a generation of artists, never sold out artistically and made critically and commercially music through their entire career.  Sounds pretty good.

I'll admit that Aerosmith was among the first names that popped into my head.

I'd feel better about throwing out names like Skynryrd, AiC, and Metallica if their great years weren't cut short by deaths to their most important members.

Red Hot Chili Peppers is also a very valid nomination. I'd also put the Allman Brothers over Skynyrd but I don't know if they qualify as a band.

My personal choice would be Tool, but if we're talking about a band that could be widely accepted, I'd probably stick with Aerosmith or Chili Peppers.

(11-23-2015, 03:40 PM)bengal_fan_in_toronto Wrote: buddy of mine and i were having this convo yesterday at the bar watching the 1pm games.

I'm a big Skynyrd fan so naturally that's my choice but he's going with The Eagles.

what say you?

E Street

AKA the heart-stopping, pants-dropping, hard-rocking, booty-shaking, earth-quaking, nerve-breaking, Viagra-taking history-making, legendary … E-STREET BAND!

(11-26-2015, 10:54 AM)CKwi88 Wrote: I'll admit that Aerosmith was among the first names that popped into my head.

I'd feel better about throwing out names like Skynryrd, AiC, and Metallica if their great years weren't cut short by deaths to their most important members.

Red Hot Chili Peppers is also a very valid nomination. I'd also put the Allman Brothers over Skynyrd but I don't know if they qualify as a band.

My personal choice would be Tool, but if we're talking about a band that could be widely accepted, I'd probably stick with Aerosmith or Chili Peppers.

Well Metallica lost their basist i believe after their second album... and then later switched there newer basest with they guy playing with ozzy.

(11-25-2015, 02:55 PM)BengalHawk62 Wrote: The mental image I have of you listening to Parliament makes me chuckle.

I have deep funk roots.  When I was much younger I saw many live P-Funk All Star shows plus Bootsy's New Rubber Band, Maceo Parker and the Horny Horns, and many others.

(11-30-2015, 01:46 PM)XenoMorph Wrote: Well Metallica lost their basist i believe after their second album...   and then later switched there newer basest with they guy playing with ozzy.

And their founder was kicked out and went on to found Megadeth...

I feel The Dead Kennedys and Black Flag both deserve honorable mention.

Van Halen gets my vote for rock

What other ground breaking rock guitarist from the U.S. had more effect worldwide?

Runner ups Aerosmith, Journey, and ZZ Top in the rock/blues-rock category.

Jimi is more known for just him... even though his band was excellent.

(12-03-2015, 12:36 AM)BengalsRocker Wrote: Van Halen gets my vote for rock

What other ground breaking rock guitarist from the U.S. had more effect worldwide?

Runner ups Aerosmith, Journey, and ZZ Top in the rock/blues-rock category.

Jimi is more known for just him... even though his band was excellent.

good call on ZZ Top.  Gibbons is one of the greatest guitarists IMHO.

(12-02-2015, 11:33 PM)jfkbengals Wrote: And their founder was kicked out and went on to found Megadeth...

That doesnt matter because that would have been before any of their albums were released...

And he was 1 of 3 founders. but was with the band all of what 2 years