To all my Bengals family I have a question. If the Bengals did an All-Time great team who are the starters Offense and Defense? WhoDey

— Corey Dillon (@coreydillon_28) December 20, 2023

Corey is on it

I got quite good feedback from my list!

Some people don't like a couple of my choices though.

Haven't seen one of these in awhile . . . note to those that are somehow still unaware . . . Max Montoya was a RG and did not line up next to Munoz.

(12-20-2023, 04:55 PM)jason Wrote: Corey is on it

Yes he is.  He played on some very bad teams and was still elite. 

QB- Burrow, Anderson, Boomer
RB- Dillon, Brooks, R.Rohnson, Mixon
FB- Neal
TE- Holman, Eifert, Tumpy, Gresham
Wr- Chase, C.Johnson, Green, Curtis, Pickens, Housh
OT-Munoz, Anderson, Whitworth
G- Max M, B.Wiiams, Lap, Zeitler
C- Barham, R.Cook

3T- Geno, Wilkerson,
NT- Krumi, Reader, Peko
E- Bacon, Hendrickson, Dunlap, J.Smith
MLB- L.Wilson, B Simmons, Bill Bergy
WLB- Vontaz, Spikes,
CB- Riley, Parrish, Joseph, E Thomas,
NB- Hall, Hilton
FS- Bates, Casanova
SS- Fulcher, Nelson

LS- Clark Harris
P- Huber
K-;Pelfry

*&#$ Corey Dillon coming around now acting like he's still part of the family. The man left throwing his equipment into the stands and badmouthed the Bengals for decades. Now that they're winning, he wants to be part of it again. Child please, go away.

Dillon is definitely in there. He was worth the price of a ticket in some pretty dark times.

(12-20-2023, 05:19 PM)Sled21 Wrote: *&#$ Corey Dillon coming around now acting like he's still part of the family. The man left throwing his equipment into the stands and badmouthed the Bengals for decades. Now that they're winning, he wants to be part of it again. Child please, go away.

Eh I couldn’t blame him. They deserved the bad-mouthing. I did plenty of it myself.

(12-20-2023, 05:19 PM)Sled21 Wrote: *&#$ Corey Dillon coming around now acting like he's still part of the family. The man left throwing his equipment into the stands and badmouthed the Bengals for decades. Now that they're winning, he wants to be part of it again. Child please, go away.

Not a single person will support you in this, unless they have similar beef.

He's basically been embraced by the fans and he has gone on the local shows and podcasts, apologised, cleared the air and is VERY much involved with doing stuff again.

He's had a troubled past, but he's moved on and become the alumnus we always wanted him to be.

(12-20-2023, 05:16 PM)J24 Wrote: QB- Burrow, Anderson, Boomer
RB- Dillon, Brooks, R.Rohnson, Mixon
FB- Neal
TE- Holman, Eifert, Tumpy, Gresham
Wr- Chase, C.Johnson, Green, Curtis, Pickens, Housh
OT-Munoz, Anderson, Whitworth
G- Max M, B.Wiiams, Lap, Zeitler
C- Barham, R.Cook

3T- Geno, Wilkerson,
NT- Krumi, Reader, Peko
E- Bacon, Hendrickson, Dunlap, J.Smith
MLB- L.Wilson, B Simmons, Bill Bergy
WLB- Vontaz, Spikes,
CB- Riley, Parrish, Joseph, E Thomas,
NB- Hall, Hilton
FS- Bates, Casanova
SS- Fulcher, Nelson

LS- Clark Harris
P- Huber
K-;Pelfry

1. Neal not only is one of the most overrated players in the modern era, we had (not in the order below):

- Jeremi
- Derrick Fenner
- Pete Johnson
- ICKEY ******* WOODS

All on this team, all infinitely better than Neal could ever have dreamt to be.

2. Who's R. Cook?

3. Pelfrey isn't even top 5 of best Ks in team history

Graham
Evan (the best, of course)
Fat Randy (as much as we hate him, he was better)
Breech (ugh)
Nuge'

(12-20-2023, 05:16 PM)J24 Wrote: QB- Burrow, Anderson, Boomer
RB- Dillon, Brooks, R.Rohnson, Mixon
FB- Neal
TE- Holman, Eifert, Tumpy, Gresham
Wr- Chase, C.Johnson, Green, Curtis, Pickens, Housh
OT-Munoz, Anderson, Whitworth
G- Max M, B.Wiiams, Lap, Zeitler
C- Barham, R.Cook

3T- Geno, Wilkerson,
NT- Krumi, Reader, Peko
E- Bacon, Hendrickson, Dunlap, J.Smith
MLB- L.Wilson, B Simmons, Bill Bergy
WLB- Vontaz, Spikes,
CB- Riley, Parrish, Joseph, E Thomas,
NB- Hall, Hilton
FS- Bates, Casanova
SS- Fulcher, Nelson

LS- Clark Harris
P- Huber
K-;Pelfry

Is that a 53 man roster?

I took it to mean starters with some tough omissions... A lot of good receivers won't make it.

(12-20-2023, 05:19 PM)Sled21 Wrote: *&#$ Corey Dillon coming around now acting like he's still part of the family. The man left throwing his equipment into the stands and badmouthed the Bengals for decades. Now that they're winning, he wants to be part of it again. Child please, go away.

I think a lot of what Corey did/said in the 90s was justified. 

This organization use to be an absolute trainwreck. 

(12-20-2023, 05:16 PM)J24 Wrote: QB- Burrow, Anderson, Boomer
RB- Dillon, Brooks, R.Rohnson, Mixon
FB- Neal
TE-  Holman, Eifert, Tumpy, Gresham
Wr- Chase, C.Johnson, Green, Curtis, Pickens, Housh
OT-Munoz, Anderson,  Whitworth
G- Max M, B.Wiiams, Lap, Zeitler
C- Barham, R.Cook

3T- Geno, Wilkerson,
NT- Krumi, Reader, Peko
E- Bacon, Hendrickson, Dunlap, J.Smith
MLB- L.Wilson, B Simmons, Bill Bergy
WLB- Vontaz, Spikes,
CB- Riley, Parrish,  Joseph, E Thomas,
NB- Hall, Hilton
FS- Bates, Casanova
SS- Fulcher, Nelson

LS- Clark Harris
P- Huber
K-;Pelfry

Chase isn't in front of Chad...yet. 

(12-20-2023, 05:19 PM)Sled21 Wrote: *&#$ Corey Dillon coming around now acting like he's still part of the family. The man left throwing his equipment into the stands and badmouthed the Bengals for decades. Now that they're winning, he wants to be part of it again. Child please, go away.

I hear ya. But at the same time, maybe he's trying to have some fun and show that he still cares about the community, and I wouldn't wanna discourage him (or anyone) from doing that. Probably took him a long time to get to that point. 

Of course, it's possible he just wants to see fans mention his name and if that's the case he can go f___ .... lol  

Shit we’ve had some good receivers.

(12-20-2023, 05:40 PM)Truck_1_0_1_ Wrote: 1. Neal not only is one of the most overrated players in the modern era, we had (not in the order below):

- Jeremi
- Derrick Fenner
- Pete Johnson
- ICKEY ******* WOODS

All on this team, all infinitely better than Neal could ever have dreamt to be.

2. Who's R. Cook?

3. Pelfrey isn't even top 5 of best Ks in team history

Graham
Evan (the best, of course)
Fat Randy (as much as we hate him, he was better)
Breech (ugh)
Nuge'

Perhaps Woods or Johnson would have been a more logical or popular choice, but I don't think its crazy talk to have Neal in that spot.  Agree or not, he's considered one of the best pure blocking fullbacks in league history, not just Bengals history.  

I'm sure he's referring to Kyle Cook (and I'm sure you're aware of that too).

I'd probably go with Shayne Graham for best kicker due to his longevity, but hopefully McPherson surpasses him soon.  Evan certainly has made more big kicks for the franchise than any of these other guys.

No backups from me. That'd be cheating. I'm going all in with this group.

QB: Burrow - captain
RB: Dillon
FB: Ickey
TE: Holman
WR: Ocho
WR: Chase
LT: Munoz - captain
LG: Kozerski
C: Karras! (I never saw Bob Johnson play)
RG: Montoya
RT: Big Willie

DE: Hendrickson
1T: Reader - captain
3T: Atkins
DE: J. Smith
MLB: L. Wilson
OLB: Reggie Williams - captain
CB: Riley
CB: Parrish
NB: Hilton - captain
FS: Bates
SS: Fulcher

K: Mac
P: Huber - captain

KR: T. Mack
PR: Pac

(12-20-2023, 05:01 PM)Truck_1_0_1_ Wrote: I got quite good feedback from my list!

Some people don't like a couple of my choices though.

And your team is? 

(12-20-2023, 05:40 PM)Truck_1_0_1_ Wrote: 1. Neal not only is one of the most overrated players in the modern era, we had (not in the order below):

- Jeremi
- Derrick Fenner
- Pete Johnson
- ICKEY ******* WOODS

All on this team, all infinitely better than Neal could ever have dreamt to be.

2. Who's R. Cook?

3. Pelfrey isn't even top 5 of best Ks in team history

Graham
Evan (the best, of course)
Fat Randy (as much as we hate him, he was better)
Breech (ugh)
Nuge'

1.) Honestly thought both Woods and and Johnson were Half backs.


2.) meant Kyle Cooke

3.) Meant Breech- I get him and Pelfry confused!