1 T Brady
2 R Wilson
3 A Rodgers
4 D Watson
5 P Mahomes
6 L Jackson
7 J Grappolo
8 D Carr
9 D Prescott
10 C Wentz
11 J Goff
12 D Brees
13 B Roethlisberger
14 P Rivers
15 J Allen
16 B Mayfield
17 K Murray
18 S Darnold
19 J Brissett
20 T Bridgewater
21 M Stafford
22 A Dalton
23 M Ryan
24 C Newton
25 D Jones
26 G Minshew
27 J Winston
28 K Cousins
29 D Haskins
30 R Tannehill
31 J Flacco
32 R Fitzpatrick
33 M Tribusky

Is it a dumb question to request the provenance of these rankings?

What's the point of the thread? More Dalton hate? He's benched and Savior Finley is the new starter. Guy wasn't having a great year. Should we post where the rest of our players rank in comparison to the rest of the League? I bet Dalton is rated higher at his position that A LOT of his teammates.

Baker Mayfield, Derrick Carr, and Ben Roethlisberger look awful high on that list.

Not sure of the basis of this ranking, but I'm pretty sure I disagree in any context ... Since we're doing random QB rankings, however, here's the top 32 in my fantasy league (total points scored) -- no, it's not relevant to anyone buy me, but at least there's a basis:

1. Watson, Deshaun
2. Wilson, Russell
3. Mahomes, Patrick
4. Rodgers, Aaron
5. Stafford, Matthew
6. Jackson, Lamar
7. Brady, Tom
8. Ryan, Matt
9. Prescott, Dak
10. Wentz, Carson
11. Cousins, Kirk
12. Minshew, Gardner
13. Brissett, Jacoby
14. Goff, Jared
15. Winston, Jameis
16. Dalton, Andy
17. Rivers, Philip
18. Jones, Daniel
19. Allen, Josh
20. Murray, Kyler
21. Carr, Derek
22. Rudolph, Mason
23. Bridgewater, Teddy
24. Keenum, Case
25. Garoppolo, Jimmy
26. Mariota, Marcus
27. Allen, Kyle
28. Flacco, Joe
29. Mayfield, Baker
30. Brees, Drew
31. Trubisky, Mitchell
32. Tannehill, Ryan

(10-31-2019, 01:32 PM)shanebo Wrote: Not sure of the basis of this ranking, but I'm pretty sure I disagree in any context ...  Since we're doing random QB rankings, however, here's the top 32 in my fantasy league (total points scored) -- no, it's not relevant to anyone buy me, but at least there's a basis:

1. Watson, Deshaun
2. Wilson, Russell
3. Mahomes, Patrick
4. Rodgers, Aaron
5. Stafford, Matthew
6. Jackson, Lamar
7. Brady, Tom
8. Ryan, Matt
9. Prescott, Dak
10. Wentz, Carson
11. Cousins, Kirk
12. Minshew, Gardner
13. Brissett, Jacoby
14. Goff, Jared
15. Winston, Jameis
16. Dalton, Andy
17. Rivers, Philip
18. Jones, Daniel
19. Allen, Josh
20. Murray, Kyler
21. Carr, Derek
22. Rudolph, Mason
23. Bridgewater, Teddy
24. Keenum, Case
25. Garoppolo, Jimmy
26. Mariota, Marcus
27. Allen, Kyle
28. Flacco, Joe
29. Mayfield, Baker
30. Brees, Drew
31. Trubisky, Mitchell
32. Tannehill, Ryan

Not sure I'm comfortable with any list that has Andy 14 spots ahead of brees

(10-31-2019, 10:07 AM)jason Wrote: Baker Mayfield, Derrick Carr, and Ben Roethlisberger look awful high on that list.

LMAO, just caught that. Pig Pen hasn't played in weeks....and Baker is dogshit this season. He better thank his lucky stars for Chubbs and that defense.

(10-31-2019, 01:47 PM)bfine32 Wrote: Not sure I'm comfortable with any list that has Andy 14 spots ahead of brees

It's a fantasy football list....Brees has missed a lot of time, so his overall scoring takes a hit.