(07-26-2015, 11:27 AM)BonnieBengal Wrote: I don't think the perceived quality of other QBs would drop him to the 5th round.  It might drop him by a round or so. But there's more here, and I think it was the "arrogant" label he got after some of the interviews.  I really think that is why he fell.  But one man's arrogance is another man's confidence.  It didn't bother the Bengals and I think they possibly got a gem here.  I'm a Dalton supporter, but if McCarron turns out to be the better QB, he'll probably be starting next year. 

(07-27-2015, 05:51 PM)Mike M (the other one) Wrote: 2. What all did you read? I read that people felt he was arrogant and considered himself the best QB in the Draft. I think people confused confidence with arrogance, he's got the titles/stats/records to back his words up.

3. With his Bum shoulder it's really hard to figure out his rankings due to the not so great Combine.

(08-01-2015, 04:46 PM)BigSeph Wrote: It's almost like you Bengals fans have Stockholm Syndrome or something when it comes to Dalton.

You will circle the wagons to defend him and put blame on AJ Green, Marvin Lewis, the defense, anyone BUT Dalton for his repeated failures.

Something positive comes along about AJ McCarron, and Bengals fans everywhere (not just specifically here) bash him, downplay it, and dismiss it.  "Oh he hasn't thrown a preseason pass yet."  Well neither have Mariota or Winston, and their respective fanbases are excited about it, they want to hear good news on those guys, the positive news feeds their hopes for the upcoming season.

Among Bengal fans, the positive news on McCarron is viewed as an assault on Dalton, and everyone attempts to downplay it to the point where some of you guys become negative when you hear positive news about your own player!

I've been lurking and reading this thread, and doing lots of research on AJ McCarron over the past few months.  Yes there have been more successful 1st round QBs than 7th round QBs, and that can be said for any other position on the football field.  But guys like Jeff Garcia and Tony Romo weren't even drafted, Tom Brady sat around forever, and sometimes the NFL scouts are restricted by what they see at the time, not what the potential is.

McCarron had a bum shoulder which affected his throwing strength.  It's fixed.

McCarron had a set of bad interviews because he viewed himself as the best QB in that class.  That remains to be seen.

McCarron worked with Tom House to improve his throwing strength, to become more efficient at QB, and he put in the work.  NFL scouts interviewing him probably viewed that behavior as an impossibility from the guy who thought he was the best QB in the world, they probably thought he would just coast (ala Manziel) and expect his natural talent to be better than anyone else's.  But Tom Brady thought that, other great QBs have thought that, and it has fueled them to become great.  They put in the work to become great and maximize that talent.

You guys have a QB here who is doing all the right things, saying all the right things, approaching it the right way, and has something already that Andy Dalton will never have - the desire to be great, the will to win, and a refusal to accept losing.  That's between the ears, it can't be taught, and even if he ends up being a great backup for a few years, can't you guys be happy with that?

Other people see so much more potential in him than a backup QB, and that's fine.  I'm one of them.

But to dismiss McCarron and rally around Dalton isn't much different than the Patriot fans who thought Bledsoe was the answer and Brady should have been benched the second Drew came back from his injury.  How'd that turn out for them?  And do you guys realize the similarity between Bledsoe's style of play at QB and Dalton's?  The appreciation of regular season stat accumulation while pretending those playoff failures are someone else's fault?

You guys will grow to love McCarron, whether you want to or not.  He'll find his way onto the football field and he won't be removed from it until he decides to retire.  He has that fire and that drive.  He has that experience in big situations, that ability to excel in them rather than lay an egg.  Andy Dalton has a career 1:6 TD:INT ratio in playoff games.  Russell Wilson?  12:6.  Roethlisberger?  21:19.  Aaron Rodgers?  23:7.  Matt Ryan?  9:7.

You don't get a chance to improve on your playoff stats when you lay an egg in every playoff game.

Remind me again why you guys defend Dalton so much and dismiss McCarron so easily?

He's the one guy on this entire team that could take you from perennial playoff 1 and done to SB contenders.

Drew Bledsoe career playoff TD:INT?  6:12.  Tom Brady?  53:26.

You'll learn to love him.

(08-01-2015, 04:51 PM)BayouBengal Wrote:

Mccarron to TE Murphy, not sure whose covering him. Touch pass caught in the endzone and it looks sweet. 

Got it from this guy's blog it has lots of images and videos from day 1 to savor over.

(08-01-2015, 04:55 PM)RoyleRedlegs Wrote: Have you ever not posted about McCarron? 

(08-01-2015, 04:55 PM)RoyleRedlegs Wrote: Have you ever not posted about McCarron? 

(08-01-2015, 04:58 PM)GreenCornBengal Wrote: He must have missed the play 2 posts earlier where McCarron threw a pick 6 to Darqueze

(08-01-2015, 04:53 PM)RoyleRedlegs Wrote: Random Bama fan checking in

(07-12-2015, 09:08 AM)EatonFan Wrote: I guess we'll see here in about a month what McCarron has at the NFL level.  Some college stars can adjust and some can't.  It is amazing how some are big time stars at college only to completely flop on the NFL stage.  I'm hoping McCarron tears it up.  Dalton gets dinged a bit.  AJ comes in and we win five straight super bowls.  I just don't see that happening.

(08-01-2015, 06:52 PM)Derrick Wrote: I hope he is successful in the NFL. I am neutral on AJ as I haven't seen him play yet. It will all work out like it is supposed to, I guess. :snark:

(08-01-2015, 04:46 PM)BigSeph Wrote: It's almost like you Bengals fans have Stockholm Syndrome or something when it comes to Dalton.

Something positive comes along about AJ McCarron, and Bengals fans everywhere (not just specifically here) bash him, downplay it, and dismiss it.

(08-02-2015, 10:41 AM)fredtoast Wrote: Typical Bama fan. Can't read what people are actually saying in this thread.

Bengal fan. "I am not rooting against McCarron.  In fact, I'd like to see him do well because it would help our team.  But, I'd just like to see him do something against NFL competition before anointing him as a great NFL starting QB"


Bama fan.  "Why do you hate McCarron so much for no reason.  Why are you defending Dalton?  How can you be so blind?  You must be suffering from some sort of mental illness.  Where are my sheets?!?!?"

Quote:Get back with us after .... you know ... he throws a pass. 

Quote:I don't hate him. I don't think he's a very good QB. 

And I'm certainly not going to dub him before has thrown even a pre-season NFL pass. 

Quote:It's just rare to find a guy who had the talents around him that a guy like McCarron had at Alabama and see that translate to NFL success.

Quote:I can really only speak for myself, but the only reason I bag on McCarron is to annoy the drooling masses that constantly call for him to start after Dalton makes his first mistake of the season. That shit gets tired - especially when we ain't even seen the dude throw a pass against a second or third string NFL defense.

Quote:I am a Vol fan. I hated McCarron in college, but even I am hoping he becomes a good NFL QB.

(08-02-2015, 12:39 PM)BigSeph Wrote:  Let the positive McCarron news wash over you like a tattoo artist linking your arm tattoos together across your chest.

(08-03-2015, 02:17 PM)XenoMorph Wrote: He Apparently isnt shining to bright so far in camp...

Maybe its a good thing they didnt cut dalton like many of you wanted.

(08-03-2015, 02:17 PM)XenoMorph Wrote: He Apparently isnt shining to bright so far in camp...

Maybe its a good thing they didnt cut dalton like many of you wanted.

(08-02-2015, 12:39 PM)BigSeph Wrote: Let me go back through the first couple pages of this thread and help you remember what was said -







Now what we know is that you've admitted you are a Tennessee fan, and you disliked McCarron, and you pulled the "but nobody's being negative about McCarron!" gag earlier in this thread.

Here's you-




Yet you seem beholden to the kidnapper of your franchise, Andy Dalton.  You continue to downplay McCarron's positive news and pretend you're keeping things in perspective, when
really you're still grinding that axe from college.  Let go.  Sit back and enjoy it.  Let the positive McCarron news wash over you like a tattoo artist linking your arm tattoos together across your chest.

Nobody is "anointing him a great starting NFL QB" right now, I think some people have commented on his potential but we all recognize that it takes experience to improve and it will take experience for him to reach his ceiling.  Again, you called out people for making a strawman earlier on this thread, and look at what you're doing.  Who has said "AJ McCarron is a great starting NFL QB - right now?"

I'm not a Bama fan.  Not everyone who think AJ McCarron will end up being a star in the NFL is wearing Bama or SEC glasses.  Just like not every 5th rounder is destined to ride the bench and hold a clipboard.