Welcome Shamar Stewart

[NUGDUKWE]

(Yesterday, 01:41 PM)Luvnit2 Wrote: For all the naysayers, what is the floor for Stewart's production the next 3 years?

Sacks
TFL
PFF or other scores against the pass and the run?

Do he need to overtake Ossai or Murphy to start inn 2025? If so when, day1 or a later date?

I am interested to see the expectations fans cast on him a day after he is picked so we can revisit it later.

College Production comparisons

Shemar Stewart
37 games, 30 solo tackles, 12 TFLs, 4.5 sacks

Trey Hendrickson
40 games, 71 solo tackles, 42 TFLs, 29.5 sacks

Sam Hubbard
40 games, 64 solo tackles, 30 TFLs, 17 sacks

Carlos Dunlap
39 games, 56 solo tackles, 27 TFLs, 19.5…

— Goodberry (@JoeGoodberry) April 25, 2025

 


I saw this earlier and thought it was an interesting comparisons. 
What's his floor? Producing an avg. of 1.5 sacks per year and 11 TFLs over a 3yr span that gives him the lowest TFL production of a drafted DE since 2000. I would say his floor is pretty dang low. I'm more curious what his ceiling is? A mid level player? Is that what we took such a risk for? 
Why didn't we take Jihad if we want to take a risk atleast we have the hope of a game changing playmaker at linebacker. I also think this is the end of Trey i don't see a world we use two 1st rd picks at a position and still pay a player a premium salary at said position. I mean we our the worst organization in the NFL. It's bad enough we apparently plan to force Trey to play out his final year but now we are gonna ask him to play it with the 1st rd pick. No other team in the league does this. Mind numbing how dumb we are. 


But I have seen as far as play time is Murphy will share time with Trey at RDE and he has looked best there while Ossai, Sample and Stewart share LDE.