Dispute or Agree?

[BengalChris]

(12-06-2017, 08:56 PM)THE PISTONS Wrote: These are the PFF grades for the players so far this year. Post if you dispute or agree. Keep in mind this isn't like Madden ratings and is based on actual play in games.

Offense
Dalton - Average (Almost Above Average)
AJ Green - High Quality - #4 WR
Lafell - Poor - #97 WR
Mixon - Above Average - #14 RB
Kroft - Average - #15 TE
Bodine - Poor - #32 Center
Boling - Average
Hopkins - Poor
Smith - Poor - #51 Tackle
Ogbuehi - Poor - #71 Tackle
Fisher - Poor - #66 Tackle

That's 6 guys rated Poor on Offense that have played A LOT this year. Mixon and Green are bright spots.

Defense
Jones - Poor - #91 CB
Kirkpatrick - Poor - Poor - #98 CB
Jackson - Above Average - #19 CB
Dennard - Average - #41 CB
Williams - Below Average
Iloka - Average - #39 Safety
Vigil - Poor - #83 LB - Our worst rated starter on the entire team.
Burfict - Above Average - #9 LB
Minter - Below Average
Billings - Poor - #105 DI
Atkins - Elite - #2 DI
Johnson - Average - #62 Edge
Dunlap - Above Average - #29 Edge
Lawson - Above Average - #30 Edge

Our defense looks better with only 4 starters rated Poor. Atkins is our only player having an Elite season.

Overall 10 guys who start are rated Poor. You're not going to win a ton of games with that.

Offense
Dalton - Average (Almost Above Average) [Given the state of the OL, I give Dalton the benefit of the doubt]
AJ Green - High Quality - #4 WR [Agreed]
Lafell - Poor - #97 WR [Agreed - Production way down this year]
Mixon - Above Average - #14 RB [Agreed]
Kroft - Average - #15 TE [Has played better than I expected he would, he's better than the eternally injured Eifert]
Bodine - Poor - #32 Center [#32 out of 32 - Yes, it wasn't my imagination. Agreed]
Boling - Average [I guess, maybe - certainly not above average]

Hopkins - Poor [Agreed]
Smith - Poor - #51 Tackle [Agreed]
Ogbuehi - Poor - #71 Tackle [Agreed]
Fisher - Poor - #66 Tackle [Agreed]

That's 6 guys rated Poor on Offense that have played A LOT this year. Mixon and Green are bright spots.

Defense
Jones - Poor - #91 CB [Disagree - I think he's better than #91]
Kirkpatrick - Poor - Poor - #98 CB [Agreed]
Jackson - Above Average - #19 CB  [Agreed - except for the play where standing there watching the Steeler run past him, otherwise he pretty good]
Dennard - Average - #41 CB  [Agreed]
Williams - Below Average  [Agreed]
Iloka - Average - #39 Safety  [Agreed]
Vigil - Poor - #83 LB - Our worst rated starter on the entire team. [Disagree on being the worst start on the entire team, but otherwise agree]
Burfict - Above Average - #9 LB [Agree - he'd be higher if he didn't get suspended each year]
Minter - Below Average  [Agreed]
Billings - Poor - #105 DI [Don't know]
Atkins - Elite - #2 DI [Agreed]
Johnson - Average - #62 Edge  [Agreed]
Dunlap - Above Average - #29 Edge  [Agreed]
Lawson - Above Average - #30 Edge [Agreed]