End of the "Dalton Scale"?

[CarolinaBengalFanGuy]

(05-21-2015, 05:48 PM)GreenCornBengal Wrote: Alex Smith was too low, Nick Foles was too high.. I think Andrew Luck could have also been higher. Peyton Manning isn't the second best anymore either.

I think if the Bengals had Alex Smith we would have gone deeper in the playoffs for sure, so I would not put him below Dalton

Manning might not be the most solid guy in the playoffs but he posted the third most touchdowns of his career in a single season last year only behind his two record setting year one of which was the 55 he threw the year before. I don't see why he can't be considered second best still.

Nick Foles yes but he's lumped in with that entire middle section of QB's and I personally like him so his ranked higher.

Alex Smith I wouldn't argue is better than Dalton at all. He's a very average QB. He's not terrible or anything but he's not noticeably better than the QB's around him.

Andrew Luck is also lumped in with a top 10 all who are pretty close with one another.