Posts: 19,565
Threads: 629
Reputation:
84016
Joined: Oct 2016
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
Here's the link to the article that's missing on Bengals.com. The article was written Jan 9, 2015. BEFORE the ill-fated Ced/Fisher draft:
https://web.archive.org/web/20150113031527/https://www.bengals.com/news/article-1/Tape-crusaders/63e02401-b155-495c-9785-d354aef1189e
Posts: 19,565
Threads: 629
Reputation:
84016
Joined: Oct 2016
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
Posts: 11,614
Threads: 131
Reputation:
59067
Joined: May 2015
It makes far more sense to scout from tape than in person. You get better angles and you can replay plays multiple times quickly to confirm what you think you see. To me scouting in person is a relic that serves little purpose in season with today's technology.
Posts: 40,628
Threads: 1,062
Joined: May 2015
It is almost impossible to scout watching live games where you can't rewind and re-watch what happened.
It is also a huge waste of time and money. In the one day that a live game would require a scout could break down film of every snap a player would take in an entire college season.
Posts: 7,774
Threads: 854
Reputation:
127740
Joined: May 2015
Location: Ohio
As Billy B said, every team is "watching the same games" and "looking at the same film".
The difference is how teams evaluate players based on those games and film, and who is doing the evaluating.
Posts: 13,628
Threads: 365
Reputation:
45805
Joined: May 2015
So basically youtube.
Quote:"Success doesn’t mean every single move they make is good" ~ Anonymous
"Let not the dumb have to educate" ~ jj22
Posts: 4,361
Threads: 26
Reputation:
19347
Joined: May 2015
Location: Lake Placid, NY
I actually have no problem with this
Posts: 16,402
Threads: 151
Reputation:
61592
Joined: May 2015
(11-04-2019, 05:46 PM)THE PISTONS Wrote: <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
who are the scouting directors directing? I mean do we really need 1 guy for each scout
Posts: 15,116
Threads: 221
Reputation:
147378
Joined: May 2015
Film's nice and all, but I think the reason "normal" teams send scouts to games is to speak with potential targets and pick their brains. Normal teams care as much about a players mental makeup as their athletic ability.
Either way, we have fewer guys to watch film or do anything scouting departments do.
The training, nutrition, medicine, fitness, playbooks and rules evolve. The athlete does not.
Posts: 13,628
Threads: 365
Reputation:
45805
Joined: May 2015
I disagree with those who say there's no point anymore. Not that I agree or disagree with the expense of it all. In person you can see how they are interacting with coaches/players not on camera. See them warm up and practice before the game. Talk to coaches. Hear the ball get caught to get an idea of QB arm strength. Interact with other scouts before teams go silent in preparation for the draft.
I think there's some pros for scouting in person.
Quote:"Success doesn’t mean every single move they make is good" ~ Anonymous
"Let not the dumb have to educate" ~ jj22
Posts: 13,440
Threads: 132
Reputation:
89190
Joined: May 2015
What about they guys they don't list like Jim McNally?
Posts: 40,628
Threads: 1,062
Joined: May 2015
(11-04-2019, 07:06 PM)Pat5775 Wrote: I actually have no problem with this
If they had NOT done it people would be complaining that they are "trapped in the past".
Posts: 1,309
Threads: 20
Reputation:
7052
Joined: May 2015
(11-04-2019, 05:48 PM)Au165 Wrote: It makes far more sense to scout from tape than in person. You get better angles and you can replay plays multiple times quickly to confirm what you think you see. To me scouting in person is a relic that serves little purpose in season with today's technology.
Scouts who attend games also have the added benefit of interacting with people and gathering additional intel. More intel generally leads to better, more informed decisions. In other words, not drafting bums like Ogbuehi and Sample.
Through 2023
Mike Brown’s Owner/GM record: 32 years 223-303-4 .419 winning pct.
Playoff Record: 5-9, .357 winning pct.
Zac Taylor coaching record, reg. season: 37-44-1. .455 winning pct.
Playoff Record: 5-2, .714 winning pct.
Posts: 5,598
Threads: 62
Reputation:
38730
Joined: May 2015
Location: Cincinnati, Ohio
Doesn't matter what the method you are using to view players, tape or live, if the guys doing the evaluating keep missing pick after pick it's time for a change in personal.
Posts: 18,617
Threads: 462
Reputation:
118131
Joined: May 2015
Location: Nashville, TN
The logic for why is sound.
I much prefer to watch a game on TV when I can get multiple angles, rewind, etc.
But as others said, different people focus on different things when viewing tape (or live).
That's the important part.
Zac Taylor 2019-2020: 6 total wins
Zac Taylor 2021-2022: Double-digit wins each season, plus 5 postseason wins
Zac Taylor 2023: 9 wins despite losing Burrow half the season
Zac Taylor 2024: Started 1-4. If he can turn this into a playoff appearance, it will be impressive.
Sorry for Party Rocking!
Posts: 5,559
Threads: 82
Reputation:
25610
Joined: May 2015
Location: Florida
If you've ever been to a game you get to see things that aren't on film. You get to see what players as they come off the field, what do they look like? what is their attitude? what is their facial expression? how do they react to the coach giving them instructions? etc. None of that is on the game film. I can see a value in going to games of guys you consider 1st and/or 2nd round picks. It kills a team when you whiff on those.
With two scouting directors, whatever that title means, and two scouts, the number of people sifting through film for the Bengals is tiny. It makes you wonder why the Bengals love big school picks. How do they have time to watch anyone else? Big schools let you watch film on more than one guy at a time.
Each year there are 254 draft picks and that many again college free agents. How do two or maybe four people watch that much film? They can't and they don't.
We've seen first hand the results of the Bengals scouting.
Posts: 28,757
Threads: 40
Reputation:
126716
Joined: May 2015
Location: Parts Unknown, PA
How do teams that win more than us handle this sort of thing?
Posts: 6,923
Threads: 104
Reputation:
32969
Joined: May 2015
Location: Cinci Burbs
(11-04-2019, 08:17 PM)BengalChris Wrote: If you've ever been to a game you get to see things that aren't on film. You get to see what players as they come off the field, what do they look like? what is their attitude? what is their facial expression? how do they react to the coach giving them instructions? etc. None of that is on the game film. I can see a value in going to games of guys you consider 1st and/or 2nd round picks. It kills a team when you whiff on those.
With two scouting directors, whatever that title means, and two scouts, the number of people sifting through film for the Bengals is tiny. It makes you wonder why the Bengals love big school picks. How do they have time to watch anyone else? Big schools let you watch film on more than one guy at a time.
Each year there are 254 draft picks and that many again college free agents. How do two or maybe four people watch that much film? They can't and they don't.
We've seen first hand the results of the Bengals scouting.
Yup agreed.
I also think as time goes on, we are going to see more and more that Marvin & his staff overachieved with such limited resources provided from the Clown family.
“Don't give up. Don't ever give up.” - Jimmy V
Posts: 5,606
Threads: 197
Reputation:
14886
Joined: May 2015
(11-04-2019, 05:43 PM)THE PISTONS Wrote: <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
Here's the link to the article that's missing on Bengals.com. The article was written Jan 9, 2015. BEFORE the ill-fated Ced/Fisher draft:
https://web.archive.org/web/20150113031527/https://www.bengals.com/news/article-1/Tape-crusaders/63e02401-b155-495c-9785-d354aef1189e
So....they watch YouTube videos? I figured that was our standard scouting practice. Sample must have had 2 thumbs up and a couple nice comments.
Posts: 19,565
Threads: 629
Reputation:
84016
Joined: Oct 2016
(11-04-2019, 08:23 PM)Nately120 Wrote: How do teams that win more than us handle this sort of thing?
Well...they have 2 to 3 times the scouts.
I guess ours are 3 times better than theirs though.
|