If Andy Reid or John Harbaugh were our HC

[shuffle]

(11-17-2024, 03:21 PM)Whacked Wrote: What do you think our record would be?

Me: 7-3

4-7. 

[Whacked]

(11-18-2024, 06:02 PM)DesertBengal Wrote: Coaching absolutely makes a big difference.

Good coaching should be getting the most from their players, putting them in position to succeed (scheme) and the overall team performing greater than the sum of their parts.

I look at the Denver Broncos and see a team where the coaching is getting the post from their players... They lost 3 first round picks trading for R. Wilson and Sean Payton, have $80m in dead cap (largely because of R. Wilson), are starting a rookie QB and their best receiver is Courtland Sutton. and they're 6 - 5.

Look what Harbaugh did with Herbert and the Chargers. They lost a lot of solid key players too.

It matters - for sure.

[*Wyche'sWarrior*]

(11-18-2024, 08:28 PM)Whacked Wrote: Look what Harbaugh did with Herbert and the Chargers. They lost a lot of solid key players too.

It matters - for sure.

It does for sure .....but I feel the defense is what's hurting this team the most. Rex Ryan said the talent is pitiful, to put it nicely, so it seems the situation in Cincinnati is a little bit different. The Chargers have some pretty good players on their defense. Herbert needed an offensive minded coach to help his progression. 

[*Wyche'sWarrior*]

(11-18-2024, 04:36 PM)Nate (formerly eliminate08) Wrote: Sucks, looking like we need to draft another Kicker. I like Rehkow though. One step forward two steps back is the way it always seems with us.

Brutal man, just brutal.

[*psychdoctor*]

Taylor is losing my confidence. It is a combination of things that go awry but ultimately, the players are not playing up to their ability. Points to coaching, preparation, and mental attitude. They have to fire DL and OL coaches over bye week. Players are not developing like they should.

[Whacked]

(11-18-2024, 08:30 PM)WychesWarrior Wrote: It does for sure .....but I feel the defense is what's hurting this team the most. Rex Ryan said the talent is pitiful, to put it nicely, so it seems the situation in Cincinnati is a little bit different. The Chargers have some pretty good players on their defense. Herbert needed an offensive minded coach to help his progression. 

Agreed but I will add that we have seen the O struggle as well and no one is going to convince me that the ridiculous talent of Burrow, Chase and Tee (when playing) wouldn’t put up even more monstrous numbers almost every game with a legit HC.

These schemes are often dog crap and the O doesn’t wake up or play for 1-2 quarters more often than not.

This talent is being short-changed badly.

[Sled21]

(11-19-2024, 04:40 AM)psychdoctor Wrote: Taylor is losing my confidence.  It is a combination of things that go awry but ultimately, the players are not playing up to their ability.  Points to coaching, preparation, and mental attitude.  They have to fire DL and OL coaches over bye week.  Players are not developing like they should.

While I'm not opposed to this, you have to have a replacement available/

[*Wyche'sWarrior*]

(11-19-2024, 09:54 AM)Whacked Wrote: Agreed but I will add that we have seen the O struggle as well and no one is going to convince me that the ridiculous talent of Burrow, Chase and Tee (when playing) wouldn’t put up even more monstrous numbers almost every game with a legit HC.  

These schemes are often dog crap and the O doesn’t wake up or play for 1-2 quarters more often than not.

This talent is being short-changed badly.

A big problem with the offense is the IOL....but you're not wrong either. 

[Whacked]

(11-17-2024, 03:21 PM)Whacked Wrote: What do you think our record would be?

9-5

[*Awful Llama*]

(11-17-2024, 03:21 PM)Whacked Wrote: What do you think our record would be?

Here's what our record would be...



every Sunday at 1:00!

[Whacked]

lol

[*bfine32*]

If we didn't win all the Super Bowlz, it would be the broken type Broken Type:

"Fire HC....has lost the locker-room....Team has given up on him.....we'd be much better with that other coach"

[Bengalstripes9]

Andy Reid would have had the same success with any of the following QB’s:
Josh Allen
Joe Burrow
Tom Brady

There are a few others I think he could have won one Super Bowl with.

[*bfine32*]

Thread makes me ask a question.

Why don't HC's go on the open market? You've never seen a HC turn down an extension to test Free Agency.

[*michaelsean*]

The best we get from our coaches is they don’t lose the game for us. As long as this coaching staff is here, I will continue to not watch. Unless they start off 8-0 or something. I’m not crazy.

[Nicomo Cosca]

(7 hours ago)michaelsean Wrote: The best we get from our coaches is they don’t lose the game for us. As long as this coaching staff is here, I will continue to not watch. Unless they start off 8-0 or something. I’m not crazy.

I’ll settle for 2-0 with Zac.

[*michaelsean*]

(7 hours ago)Nicomo Cosca Wrote: I’ll settle for 2-0 with Zac.

You make a good point

[Bengalstripes9]

(7 hours ago)bfine32 Wrote: Thread makes me ask a question.

Why don't HC's go on the open market? You've never seen a HC turn down an extension to test Free Agency.

Coaching is what wins in the nfl.
If you pair an elite qb with an elite coach that will win more often than not.

Bengals have an elite qb, but they lack the elite game planning of an elite coach.
They also lack a defense and decisive vision for said defense (identity/scheme).

If you look at teams like the chiefs and eagles, their defenses weren’t good enough and their coaches/GM made the right picks in the draft to build a defense. They loaded up on pass rush and coverage. They backed up the defense with great game planning and game management to win more often than not in close games.

Meanwhile the bengals tend to shell up on offense in the clutch/playoffs against elite teams in crucial moments.
Bengals could have won when they made the Super Bowl and afc championship a couple years ago if their offense could close out the game—but they got outcoached in the clutch moments.
They’ve gotten outcoached in clutch moments this year too.

Bengals keep wiffing on defense in the draft.
They have punted drafting a legit corner since Zac got here.
They picked up a couple mid DTs in FA to replace an aging Reader.
Chiefs drafted later than the bengals and still drafted better to set up these last 3 years. They were up against the salary cap just like us but hit on their picks.

I brought this up before this draft and the prior one as well.
Bengals need a great draft on defense to set up a Super Bowl window.
Their coaching needs to improve as well.
Part of coaching is drafting, development, and game planning/management.

Zac has had some moments where we won some close games.
Overall we keep coming up short and it’s a case of the coaches and the organization wiffing on draft picks and not getting us into the right plays in the clutch situations to win games.

[*rfaulk34*]

I crunched all the applicable numbers and came up with the very scientific results of...


100eleventy.5 - potato

You can't beat science.