Posts: 19,594
Threads: 486
Reputation:
127200
Joined: May 2015
Location: Nashville, TN
Many of us (including myself) have been critical of this Bengals draft class.
Many national media sites are rating the Bengals draft one of the worst in the league.
So the question posed to you...looking at who was available at each pick, who would you have taken?
*Assume no trades because we don't know what was offered, only who was available.
Mine:
1) Derrick Harmon, DT Oregon
2) Tate Ratledge, OG Georgia
3) Xavier Watts, SAF Notre Dame
4) Kyle Kennard, DE South Carolina
5) Mitchell Evans, TE Notre Dame
6) Tahj Brooks, RB Texas Tech
Off-ball LB is one of the cheaper positions to address in FA, so I would have been perfectly ok not adding a LB in the draft. I would have been ok with just 1 LB though.
Zac Taylor 2019-2020: 6 total wins
Zac Taylor 2021-2022: Double-digit wins each season, plus 5 postseason wins
Zac Taylor 2023: 9 wins despite losing Burrow half the season
Zac Taylor 2024: Started 1-4. Ended 9-8 but barely missed playoffs
Changes needed to do better in Sept/Oct moving forward.
Sorry for Party Rocking!
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 123
Reputation:
50648
Joined: May 2015
Location: Hyborea
I probably go like this:
I already had us going with Fairchild, Tahj Brooks and Knight. I'm probably taking Green in 1, Watts over Carter and still take Rivers now that I know more about him.
Posts: 5,647
Threads: 198
Reputation:
14974
Joined: May 2015
Think I would have liked to see Harmon and Zabel over Stewart and Knight. Stewart is the only guy I didn’t want in the first. I knew we would sit still as our guy goes right before us, as usual. 6 picks, not much to work with though in a draft when teams aren’t trading.
But we have these guys now so I will give the rooks 100% support till proven otherwise. I’m just glad we addressed both lines. Would have been fine with an all O & D line draft too. Let’s Go!
Posts: 3,943
Threads: 20
Reputation:
12833
Joined: Apr 2021
I'd probably go
Harmon
Ratledge
Winston
Then just leave the rest the same although I could've gone edge or another LB in the Rivers spot.
Posts: 6,227
Threads: 145
Reputation:
29068
Joined: Dec 2021
(Yesterday, 06:43 PM)ochocincos Wrote: Many of us (including myself) have been critical of this Bengals draft class.
Many national media sites are rating the Bengals draft one of the worst in the league.
So the question posed to you...looking at who was available at each pick, who would you have taken?
*Assume no trades because we don't know what was offered, only who was available.
Mine:
1) Derrick Harmon, DT Oregon
2) Tate Ratledge, OG Georgia
3) Xavier Watts, SAF Notre Dame
4) Kyle Kennard, DE South Carolina
5) Mitchell Evans, TE Notre Dame
6) Tahj Brooks, RB Texas Tech
Off-ball LB is one of the cheaper positions to address in FA, so I would have been perfectly ok not adding a LB in the draft. I would have been ok with just 1 LB though.
I’d stay with Stewart at 1. They need an edge more than DT. Would have gone with Ratledge at 2. I’d taken Watts too. Maybe moved up to get Knight after Watts or kept Barrett at 4 if Knight was gone. The rest I liked. I’m convinced there was a battle over Ratledge vs Knight in the war room. They don’t need a TE
Romo “ so impressed with Zac ...1 of the best in the NFL… they are just fundamentally sound. Taylor the best winning % in the Playoffs of current coaches. Joe Burrow” Zac is the best head coach in the NFL & that gives me a lot of confidence." Taylor led the Bengals to their first playoff win since 1990, ending the longest active drought in the four major North American sports, en and appeared in Super Bowl LVI, the first since 1988.
Posts: 6,227
Threads: 145
Reputation:
29068
Joined: Dec 2021
(Yesterday, 08:16 PM)TKUHL Wrote: Think I would have liked to see Harmon and Zabel over Stewart and Knight. Stewart is the only guy I didn’t want in the first. I knew we would sit still as our guy goes right before us, as usual. 6 picks, not much to work with though in a draft when teams aren’t trading.
But we have these guys now so I will give the rooks 100% support till proven otherwise. I’m just glad we addressed both lines. Would have been fine with an all O & D line draft too. Let’s Go!
I wanted Zabel at 1. I understand the DE was a greater worry. Zabel went next after Stewart
Romo “ so impressed with Zac ...1 of the best in the NFL… they are just fundamentally sound. Taylor the best winning % in the Playoffs of current coaches. Joe Burrow” Zac is the best head coach in the NFL & that gives me a lot of confidence." Taylor led the Bengals to their first playoff win since 1990, ending the longest active drought in the four major North American sports, en and appeared in Super Bowl LVI, the first since 1988.
Posts: 9,160
Threads: 225
Reputation:
31605
Joined: May 2015
Location: Fredericksburg Virginia
1st Tate Ratledge RG Georgia- Day one starter at RG. Has all the data of a first RD pick.
2nd- Ashton Gillotte DE Louisville- Versatile Edge that can rush the pass rusher from the inside on third downs.
3rd- Jared Wilson C Georgia- eventual plus starter at IOL.
4th- Shedure Sanders QB- Developmental QB that I probably can trade later for significant draft capital.
5th- Jalen Rivers OT Miami- Only pick I really like what the Bengals did.
6th- Hunter Wholer S Wisconsin- Goodberry had a first RD Grade on him and grid iron grading was high on him as well.
Not a sexy draft but an effective one.
Posts: 3,943
Threads: 20
Reputation:
12833
Joined: Apr 2021
(Yesterday, 08:47 PM)J24 Wrote: 1st Tate Ratledge RG Georgia- Day one starter at RG. Has all the data of a first RD pick.
2nd- Ashton Gillotte DE Louisville- Versatile Edge that can rush the pass rusher from the inside on third downs.
3rd- Jared Wilson C Georgia- eventual plus starter at IOL.
4th- Shedure Sanders QB- Developmental QB that I probably can trade later for significant draft capital.
5th- Jalen Rivers OT Miami- Only pick I really like that the Bengals did.
6th- Hunter Wholer S Wisconsin- Goodberry had a first RD Grade on him and so did the Anylitics Twitter account I follow.
Not a sexy draft but an effective one.
Interesting draft. I do like the idea of taking a QB falling like that because if he turns into something it can change your team from a trade value aspect.
Posts: 18,103
Threads: 240
Reputation:
149305
Joined: Oct 2015
Fair enough. Lets go with...
1. Jihaad Campbell, LB
2. Tate Ratledge, OG
3. Josiah Stewart, LB (he would be our 2-down guy who can also give us potential 5-man fronts out of base defense to rush the passer)
4. Jack Sawyer, DE
5. Zah Frazier, CB
6. Ricky White, WR (6th rounders make the team for ST and he was ST PoY for his conference, also productive at WR)
Was tempted to put Quinn Ewers in the 6th because that's just great value and I think he'll have one of those great backups that occasionally is a starter-for-a-year type careers), but we need WR depth and good ST guys more than we need a new backup QB.
____________________________________________________________
Posts: 6,227
Threads: 145
Reputation:
29068
Joined: Dec 2021
(Yesterday, 08:47 PM)J24 Wrote: 1st Tate Ratledge RG Georgia- Day one starter at RG. Has all the data of a first RD pick.
2nd- Ashton Gillotte DE Louisville- Versatile Edge that can rush the pass rusher from the inside on third downs.
3rd- Jared Wilson C Georgia- eventual plus starter at IOL.
4th- Shedure Sanders QB- Developmental QB that I probably can trade later for significant draft capital.
5th- Jalen Rivers OT Miami- Only pick I really like that the Bengals did.
6th- Hunter Wholer S Wisconsin- Goodberry had a first RD Grade on him and so did the Anylitics Twitter account I follow.
Not a sexy draft but an effective one.
Sanders LMAO
Romo “ so impressed with Zac ...1 of the best in the NFL… they are just fundamentally sound. Taylor the best winning % in the Playoffs of current coaches. Joe Burrow” Zac is the best head coach in the NFL & that gives me a lot of confidence." Taylor led the Bengals to their first playoff win since 1990, ending the longest active drought in the four major North American sports, en and appeared in Super Bowl LVI, the first since 1988.
Posts: 14,226
Threads: 379
Reputation:
48547
Joined: May 2015
This thread just frustrates me all over again. I have no doubt many on this board could draft better than Tobin.
Even his best picks we had sniffed out and knew was coming. What he has t done is draft a gem. A name we weren’t familiar with. And that name turn into a special player. That’s what he gets paid to do.
Quote:"Success doesn’t mean every single move they make is good" ~ Anonymous
"Let not the dumb have to educate" ~ jj22
Posts: 40,235
Threads: 945
Reputation:
141802
Joined: May 2015
RD 1: Shemar Stewart
RD2: Tate Ratledge
RD3: Xavier Watts
RD4: Rylie Myles
RD5: Smael Mourton
RD6: Hayden Conner
Posts: 8,020
Threads: 289
Reputation:
33190
Joined: May 2015
1. Shemar - now that I know who/what he is. I didn't bother to look into him with all the hate i saw. I'm still in shock after seeing him play that we got him at 17, just absolutely wrecking an offense looking like Myles Garret.
2. mike green DE - would have had to double down with the value here.
3. xavier watts S - Going against Al is probably stupid since he should know, but it may have been an O vs D choice that determined the pick.
4. Chris Paul Jr LB - Sean Mcvay liked him enough. I know I did.
5. Miles Frazier G - Dan Campbell picked him. I liked the LSU Burrow link plug and play RG.
6. Cameron Williams T/G - Eagles picked the giant true junior that started for Texas at RT who is loaded with potential.
Posts: 2,423
Threads: 80
Reputation:
10475
Joined: May 2015
(Yesterday, 06:43 PM)ochocincos Wrote: Many of us (including myself) have been critical of this Bengals draft class.
Many national media sites are rating the Bengals draft one of the worst in the league.
So the question posed to you...looking at who was available at each pick, who would you have taken?
*Assume no trades because we don't know what was offered, only who was available.
Mine:
1) Derrick Harmon, DT Oregon
2) Tate Ratledge, OG Georgia
3) Xavier Watts, SAF Notre Dame
4) Kyle Kennard, DE South Carolina
5) Mitchell Evans, TE Notre Dame
6) Tahj Brooks, RB Texas Tech
Off-ball LB is one of the cheaper positions to address in FA, so I would have been perfectly ok not adding a LB in the draft. I would have been ok with just 1 LB though.
Your picks 2 and 3 are what I had in NY only mock. I'm going to assume the Bengals had Harmon as the next guy up if no trade so that's mint too. Probably would have had Sawyer in the 4th.
Posts: 7,259
Threads: 110
Reputation:
54625
Joined: May 2016
(Yesterday, 08:32 PM)NUGDUKWE Wrote: I'd probably go
Harmon
Ratledge
Winston
Then just leave the rest the same although I could've gone edge or another LB in the Rivers spot.
 I agree, this would have been a great use of the top three picks.
Posts: 8,613
Threads: 132
Reputation:
58075
Joined: May 2015
Location: Cincinnati
1. Harmon
2. Ratledge
3. Watts/Winston (Coaches' choice)
4. Carter
5. Mbow (though I do like the Rivers pick too).
6. Brooks
Our day 3 really was fantastic. I only change Rivers to Mbow because that's who I was more familiar with. I think they're equivalent prospects.
In reality, we didn't address interior pressure, which I felt was a more pressing need than edge pressure, so I fix that discrepancy here. I tried to fit an edge in somewhere, but I just liked these players' value better in each round.
If you wanted to change Carter to someone like David Walker to get that added edge pressure from the LB room, I wouldn't mind that change.
Posts: 6,243
Threads: 890
Reputation:
15806
Joined: May 2015
(Yesterday, 06:43 PM)ochocincos Wrote: Many of us (including myself) have been critical of this Bengals draft class.
Many national media sites are rating the Bengals draft one of the worst in the league.
So the question posed to you...looking at who was available at each pick, who would you have taken?
*Assume no trades because we don't know what was offered, only who was available.
Mine:
1) Derrick Harmon, DT Oregon
2) Tate Ratledge, OG Georgia
3) Xavier Watts, SAF Notre Dame
4) Kyle Kennard, DE South Carolina
5) Mitchell Evans, TE Notre Dame
6) Tahj Brooks, RB Texas Tech
Off-ball LB is one of the cheaper positions to address in FA, so I would have been perfectly ok not adding a LB in the draft. I would have been ok with just 1 LB though.
Bengals could have lost Higgins and Chase, but they put out huge money to keep both long term with Burrow. That right there is a great off season. Still, the Bengals Defense has not been good. Bengals brought in a new D Coach in Golden, getting him to leave a top job at Notre Dame. Much of the draft was on Defense and O Line Blockers with Bengals weak in the trenches.
I don't think me or any on this site could have did better. They had to break the bank to have Burrow, Chase and Higgins locked in long term. They brought in Golden as new D coach and he likes the D players Bengals just drafted. Golden says they fit the type defense he intends to have. The DE and LB first 2 rounds, Golden says they can play in multiple packages, so he won't get caught with the wrong players on the field, since the 2 top picks can line up in different formations.
Golden also mentioned sometimes he may need 4 LB's on the field. That is a change from Zac Taylor saying 5 or 6 DB's on the field 80 % of the game. I think Taylor will still insist on Nickle and Dime packages, but Golden sounds like he wants to also use 3 or 4 LB sets during games also. Not just sitting back in The Prevent all game as Zac likes. I think Golden was a much needed addition, and if he is happy with the players drafted, that is fine with me.
So Chase and Higgins were kept to be long term with Burrow. Most of NFL thought that impossible. That right there makes a good off season. Add in Golden and Golden liking the D players drafted, and that makes a Great off season. None of on here could have did better.
I think most of you are going to change your tune when Bengals are winning. You will say, " Oh, I see. They kept Burrow, Chase and Higgins and this Golden and his new Defense is so much better. Now we see. ".
Golden is not going to sit back in The Prevent giving up yards as Zac has done. Golden wants to mix in 3 and 4 LB packages with those extra DB packages Taylor likes. Problem was Bengals didn't have enough Front 7 players for Golden to run his Defenses, so they drafted some players so Golden can run his 3 or 4 LB sets when he wants. Taylor likes 5 and 6 DB Nickle and Dime Prevent Defenses. Golden just said there will be times he will have 3 or 4 LB's on the field. So look for Golden to run many more D Packages than Bengals have ever ran before. Golden mentioned a 4th LB sometimes, but they will still have their 5 or 6 DB sets.
I bet this was made clear at the start. Golden had a top job at Notre Dame, he didn't need Bengals. I'm sure he let it be known that he would not leave Notre Dame to play The Prevent Defense all game as Zac Taylor likes. However if he could mix in more 3 and 4 LB packages and run his Defense, he would leave Notre Dame for Bengals. Golden did not have to leave Notre Dame, so when Golden says he is going to run his Defense with Bengals, I believe him.
Nobody on this board could have did better including me. GO BENGALS. Higgins and Chase could be gone, but they are here, and Golden brought in to fix the Defense. It's all good.
1968 Bengal Fan
Posts: 7,565
Threads: 56
Reputation:
52988
Joined: May 2015
I would probably go given 20/20 hindsight...
1.Stewart -after hearing about the flexibility Al coveted
2.Scourton-was very high on him and you can't have enough pass rushers.
3.Jared Wilson-Highest RAS ever by a C is too good to pass up in the 3rd.
4.Carter
5.Rivers
6.Brooks
Posts: 7,352
Threads: 55
Reputation:
104210
Joined: May 2015
Location: Barrie, Ontario, Canada
1. Jihaad
2. Ratledge
3. Ty Robinson
4. Kennard
5. Miles Frazier
6. Thomas Perry
Posts: 14,226
Threads: 379
Reputation:
48547
Joined: May 2015
(3 hours ago)Whatever Wrote: I would probably go given 20/20 hindsight...
1.Stewart -after hearing about the flexibility Al coveted
2.Scourton-was very high on him and you can't have enough pass rushers.
3.Jared Wilson-Highest RAS ever by a C is too good to pass up in the 3rd.
4.Carter
5.Rivers
6.Brooks
Scourton is the one jumping off the screen when watching game tape on Stewart....
Quote:"Success doesn’t mean every single move they make is good" ~ Anonymous
"Let not the dumb have to educate" ~ jj22
|