What would you have given up to get Luck?

[West Union KennyG]

I would have to think really hard about trading AD straight up for Luck. Both are good QB's, don't get me wrong. I just like what we got too. So to answer your question about giving up all that for him? That's crazy talk right there! I think both AD and Luck will be leading their respective teams to good things for years to come, but so far AD has at least carried his team to the playoffs for a shot at it every year he's been here, and Luck may make it this year only because they play in The AFC South - that's the only reason, because they look horrible this year!

[magikod]

(06-25-2015, 02:07 AM)J24 Wrote: I wouldn't trade for Andrew Luck because the price would be to high to justify it. I would rather have Andy with a great team surrounding him then Andrew Luck with a mediocre roster.

agreed, you need more than just an elite qb.

[StLucieBengal]

Luck would change the way our team plays as well. Just as CP did in 2005.

I like the make up of our team. It's naive to think we would still be running the ball 52% of the time with Luck at QB.