Dalton & McCarron are in a very awkward situation

[*Wyche'sWarrior*]

(01-07-2016, 05:56 PM)Ravage Wrote: It's not BS, the statement I took issue with spoke in an absolute context. I set out to disprove that statement. Want a better example? Fine. Steve Young replacing Joe Montana. A journeyman QB if I ever saw one (He washed out of TAMPA before Dungy arrived and made them an actual NFL team) replacing a no-doubt HOF'er who still had plenty left in the tank (albeit not HOF level play).

I never said Dalton wasn't better than those three in either of my posts. If I did I'd love to see it. Nor did I at any point suggest that McCarron ever outperformed Dalton. I also never at any point suggested that McCarron should replace Dalton either. 

Of course, I fully expect you to keep ignoring that.

Edit: Brooks outplayed Blake?
Brooks: 3-2, 58.2%, 9/6 TD/INT, 85.7 QB rating.
Blake: 7-4, 60.9%, 13/9 TD/INT, 82.7 QB rating.
They look awful similar to me. Except only one of those two ever intentionally threw a pass backwards...to no one. And it wasn't Blake. https://vine.co/v/OJlitxm1Z6T

To be fair.....our own Sam Wyche laid the groundwork for that team by drafting Brooks, Lynch, and Sapp, and the team had improved to 7-9 his last season after a very grim outlook leading up to his tenure.  Steve Young left Tampa LONG before either Dungy or Wyche got there.  NO ONE was going to do well for the Yuccaneers in those days.  Also, Young had a pretty damn good career in the USFL before landing in NFL Siberia.