05-05-2016, 12:05 PM
(05-05-2016, 10:24 AM)oncemoreuntothejimbreech Wrote: Did you expect Mathis to thank Coach Mudd two seasons before he coached Mathis? I know Coach Mudd is good, but he isn't so good players travel backwards through time to thank him before he has had a chance to coach them.
he did nmot have to thank coach Mudd because Mudd had not coached him yet. this was in 2009. PFF aid he was as good as any guard then and that was BEFORE Mudd coached him.
(05-05-2016, 10:24 AM)oncemoreuntothejimbreech Wrote: If Alexander is a good as you claim, why did Mathis have years of bad tape as you also claim? Why did he go from backing up Nate Livings (who was out of the league one season after leaving the Bengals) to a starter after one preseason with the Eagles?
This has been explained to you dozens of times. Mathis got fat and out of shape for the '10 season. Even he admitted this. Mathis even posted a video showing himself getting back in shape before the '11 season.
Paul was giving Mathis starts in '09 when he was in shape and playing well. He didn't give him any starts in '19 because Mathis was out of shape. That is why Mathis had to settle for a league minimum contract after the '10 season despite playing so well in '09 before he got injured.
