The Bodine Witch Hunt

[TGISunday]

(05-05-2016, 08:32 PM)fredtoast Wrote: Oh, really?  because from everything I have been reading you have been claiming that paul was stupid to let Mathis go after the '10 season because it should have been clear that he was a great player.  But if you are going to make that argfument then you are going to have to say that every other O-liner coach in the leaguer was also stupid because Mathis could mnot get anything more than a league minimum contract.



Livings was injured his firat year in dallas.  he played injured and had surgery right after the season.  he did not fully recover and had another "procedure" on his knee before training camp.  The Cowboys worked out an injury settlement.  He was out of thre league due to injury.


Every NFL team was able to see those 114 snaps and Mathis looked so bad he could not get more than a league minimum contract.  This is you again claiming that you are smarter than every other GM and O-line coach in the league.  Mathis looked bad.  That is why he was playing behind Livings instead of winning starting time like he did before he was hurt in '09.

Seriously, just listen to what you are trying to argue.  .  .  "Mathis's play did not change from '09 to '10.  Instead Paul Alexander just forgot who Mathis was during the off season and could not remember that he was starting Mathis the year before."