09-14-2015, 03:36 PM
(09-14-2015, 03:29 PM)Luvnit2 Wrote: I stated upfront we all have different criteria
I did not realize I was obligated to post the 100 different things I consider, I thought a summary of a few would suffice for most and most would get the point of my post
I understand that we all have different criteria.
The fact is that one of your guys that you deemed elite does NOT fit your own criteria. I'm honestly not sure why I'm wasting the time to explain this to somebody.
If you said "I believe Antonio Brown is an elite receiver and A.J., Dez, and Julio aren't". That's fine. I'd think you're a bit crazy, but that's fine and I probably wouldn't argue much.
If you say "I believe to be elite you have to be future HOF and not just HOF potential, therefore AB is elite and A.J., Dez, and Julio aren't", that's not fine because it makes absolutely ZERO sense. AB isn't any more of a lock than the other guys. In fact, Dez Bryant has a more impressive resume than any of the others, and I have no idea on which planet he isn't considered the clear #1/2 receiver in the NFL.
The issue isn't that you believe AB is elite, that's not the problem here. You don't need to post the 100 different things you consider. The ONE thing you did post of your criteria doesn't match AB though, so that's where the issue comes in. I'd love to say that I'm surprised here but after dealing with your stubborn bullshit on the other board, I'm really not.
