The Bodine Witch Hunt

[coachmcneil71]

(05-05-2016, 12:15 PM)fredtoast Wrote: Actually you are the one going through mental gymnastics to try and blame it all on Paul.  Here is what you are trying to argue.  . .  

"Paul was smart enough to start giving Mathis starts over Livings in '09 but then just totally forgot about that in '10 and stopped playing Mathis for no reason at all. Then for some reason every other team in the league also forgot that Mathis was good and only gave him a league minimum contract"


That makes no sense at all compared to the reality that i am explaining to you.  .  .  

"Mathis played well in '09 and started earning starts, but he got injured which effected his play for the rest of that season..  When he returned for the '10 season he was fat and out of shape.  He did not get to play much in '10 because he did not deserve to.  Then after the season he was forced to take a league minimum contract because of this.  However he admitted that he was fat and out of shape in '10 and even posted a video of himself getting back in shape for the '11 season.  When he got back in shape he was good again."


The only thing comical around here is that anyone would believe the first explanation instead of the second one.

 It's more than obvious that you have lost this jury counselor. If this debate were a trial your client went from receiving 5-10, to getting the chair!