05-09-2016, 02:19 PM
(05-09-2016, 01:47 PM)fredtoast Wrote: No he did not. From the story you linked...
"the pain stretched all the way back to June 2, 2007 during a minicamp practice he originally suffered the break".
It is clear that the injury bwas to the same foot
Not according to the report from the guy who works for the Bengals. Are you admitting I can't believe Hobson's and the Bengals' injury information?
Quote:The way I took it he was cleared to go back to practice and that is when he noticed the continued pain.
They would know from the xrays before he was cleared to practice if it hadn't healed all the way.
Quote:Are you seriously claiming that for some reason JJ was trying to lie about his former injury? Why would he do that? And how can you claim top know more thanthe doctors that actually examined him? That is just ridiculous.
I'm not stating Joseph lied, but studies show patients only remember 20% of what their doctor tells them and 50% of that is wrong. Meaning they only remember 10% of what you tell them accurately.
In order for me to claim to know more than the doctors that actually examined him, you would need to have a statement from those doctors. Show me one statement any of his doctors made about the injuries in question. Just a single sentence. You can't. All you can show is media reports which can't correctly identify which foot, when it happened, or what kind of fracture. You're a lawyer so I know you're smart enough to understand you don't have a shred of objective evidence. You don't even have a first person quote. You have second hand quotes from reporters who again can't agree on which foot was broken or when it was broken.
Go back to defending Alexander and Bratkowski.
