Posts: 2,614
Threads: 2
Reputation:
12142
Joined: Oct 2020
(10-14-2023, 12:57 AM)Shake n Blake Wrote: I'd say Hendrickson is better than just "top 10". Also, to say it's "not close" is a bit much. We're talking about a guy with 28 sacks in 36 games as a Bengal.
Nevermind all he's done in the playoffs, which is better than Atkins and Dunlap combined.
I don't think Hendrickson will be this dominant as long as Atkins was, but if he was, he'd be in the HOF conversation as well.
I'm just looking at it this way. There were times when Atkins carried the pass rush, and Hendrickson is very much doing the same thing.
As far as Dunlap, we can agree to disagree. Run defense is overrated, imo. The guys who get the most accolades are the guys bringing it to the QB's, and Hendrickson does that better than Dunlap did for the majority of his career. You can sub in a guy for the run.
I love those 2 dudes. Especially Atkins. I meant no disrespect to them, and I doubt they'd take a Trey Hendrickson comparison as an insult. The dude is a baller. I don't think his peak will last long, but it's as good as any peak I've seen, imo.
Getting the most accolades and being the most impactful are still two different things. That's like saying Fields is a top 10 QB because he was a great fantasy QB. Sacks is only part of a DEs job and Hendrickson is below average at the other part, run stopping. Geno was good at both. Like I said, I would take Hendrickson over Dunlap but to equate him to Geno is overeating him, at least in my opinion.
Posts: 17,290
Threads: 239
Reputation:
137105
Joined: Oct 2015
(10-14-2023, 12:57 AM)Shake n Blake Wrote: I don't think Hendrickson will be this dominant as long as Atkins was, but if he was, he'd be in the HOF conversation as well.
I'm just looking at it this way. There were times when Atkins carried the pass rush, and Hendrickson is very much doing the same thing.
As far as Dunlap, we can agree to disagree. Run defense is overrated, imo. The guys who get the most accolades are the guys bringing it to the QB's, and Hendrickson does that better than Dunlap did for the majority of his career. You can sub in a guy for the run.
I love those 2 dudes. Especially Atkins. I meant no disrespect to them, and I doubt they'd take a Trey Hendrickson comparison as an insult. The dude is a baller. I don't think his peak will last long, but it's as good as any peak I've seen, imo.
The Bengals 5-13 record against the Browns and Ravens under Anarumo would disagree that run defense is overrated. Being able to stop the run (and in today's NFL being able to keep the QB contained) is still extremely important.
The Eagles nearly broke an all-time sack record... but couldn't get a single sack in the SB because they got ran all over by the Chiefs.
Also being a good run defender separates the great DEs from the elite DEs.
- - - - -
I do think it is kind of a disrespect to pair the two up when you say he's just as impactful. Hendrickson is great, but there's a reason he's not an All-Pro, or why he wasn't ranked the 29th best player in the NFL by his peers like Atkins was. If we want people to take our players seriously as Hall of Fame candidates, we can't be comparing them to clearly lesser (even if great) players just because they're current and we like them.
Actually reminds me a bit of when people early were trying to say AJ Green was the best WR the Bengals have ever had. Like Chad wasn't arguably the best WR in the NFL for a 3 year span and a top-3 WR for a 5 year span. Not to say AJ wasn't great, he was, but Chad just reached a completely different peak.
____________________________________________________________
1
Posts: 15,116
Threads: 221
Reputation:
147378
Joined: May 2015
(10-14-2023, 01:23 AM)TheFan Wrote: Getting the most accolades and being the most impactful are still two different things. That's like saying Fields is a top 10 QB because he was a great fantasy QB. Sacks is only part of a DEs job and Hendrickson is below average at the other part, run stopping. Geno was good at both. Like I said, I would take Hendrickson over Dunlap but to equate him to Geno is overeating him, at least in my opinion.
Who are the top run defenders in the league? How much are they paid? Now who are the top pass rushers, and how much are they paid? I'm not alone on this opinion.
I feel like sacks are viewed as a "casual" stat, so some thumb their nose at sacks and point to pressures (also very important) and run defense (less important).
I'm not saying run defense doesn't matter. It very much does. I just view it as more of a team stat. One dude isn't typically going to stop the run on his own.
That said, one guy can get to the QB.
(10-14-2023, 02:15 AM)TheLeonardLeap Wrote: The Bengals 5-13 record against the Browns and Ravens under Anarumo would disagree that run defense is overrated. Being able to stop the run (and in today's NFL being able to keep the QB contained) is still extremely important.
The Eagles nearly broke an all-time sack record... but couldn't get a single sack in the SB because they got ran all over by the Chiefs.
Also being a good run defender separates the great DEs from the elite DEs.
- - - - -
I do think it is kind of a disrespect to pair the two up when you say he's just as impactful. Hendrickson is great, but there's a reason he's not an All-Pro, or why he wasn't ranked the 29th best player in the NFL by his peers like Atkins was. If we want people to take our players seriously as Hall of Fame candidates, we can't be comparing them to clearly lesser (even if great) players just because they're current and we like them.
Actually reminds me a bit of when people early were trying to say AJ Green was the best WR the Bengals have ever had. Like Chad wasn't arguably the best WR in the NFL for a 3 year span and a top-3 WR for a 5 year span. Not to say AJ wasn't great, he was, but Chad just reached a completely different peak.
1. See what I said to TheFan about the run.
2. I'm not comparing their entire careers. Geno unquestionably had the better career. Especially when you factor his position. Hendrickson is likely to have a very short peak. That said, that's all I'm comparing. Their peaks.
If this is about who had a better career when all is said and done, it will be Geno, by a mile.
The training, nutrition, medicine, fitness, playbooks and rules evolve. The athlete does not.
Posts: 8,817
Threads: 219
Reputation:
29966
Joined: May 2015
Location: Fredericksburg Virginia
Hendrickson and Dunlap are two different style of players.
Hendrickson is a pure speed threat while Carlos is a unicorn type player. I don't know if you can really say which one is better because of that.
If I had to pick one it would be Dunlap because he impacted the game in all three areas. Run defense, Pass rush, and coverage( knocking down passes ).
Posts: 17,290
Threads: 239
Reputation:
137105
Joined: Oct 2015
(10-14-2023, 04:00 AM)Shake n Blake Wrote: 2. I'm not comparing their entire careers. Geno unquestionably had the better career. Especially when you factor his position. Hendrickson is likely to have a very short peak. That said, that's all I'm comparing. Their peaks.
Yes, and at his peak Geno was....
1. 1st Team All-Pro
2. The 29th best player in the league according to his peers
3. The best player in the league at his position
...Hendrickson is none of those.
____________________________________________________________
Posts: 11,577
Threads: 19
Reputation:
79828
Joined: May 2015
Location: Where Mr. Kotter was before returning
(10-14-2023, 11:20 AM)J24 Wrote: Hendrickson and Dunlap are two different style of players.
Hendrickson is a pure speed threat while Carlos is a unicorn type player. I don't know if you can really say which one is better because of that.
If I had to pick one it would be Dunlap because he impacted the game in all three areas. Run defense, Pass rush, and coverage( knocking down passes ).
He'd run guys down from behind too. A couple of pick 6's (pretty sure one was a game saving play vs the Colts) and at least one fumble recovery for a TD in his time here too.
Poo Dey
Posts: 17,290
Threads: 239
Reputation:
137105
Joined: Oct 2015
(10-14-2023, 03:08 PM)jason Wrote: He'd run guys down from behind too. A couple of pick 6's (pretty sure one was a game saving play vs the Colts) and at least one fumble recovery for a TD in his time here too.
Yeah, Hendrickson is playing great this year, but the previous two years he had 32 and 34 total tackles which were the two highest of his career. Dunlap's highest were 63 and 66 tackles. It's not an insignificant difference in playing the run.
Hendrickson is still a great player and a great pass rusher, but he's not really a complete player which will always knock him down a notch. Dunlap isn't on their level as a pass rusher, but the elite complete players like Garrett and Twatt are also 50-60 tackle guys.
Ultimately that's another factor for me. At Atkins peak he was the best DT in the entire NFL. At Hendrickson's peak he's the 3rd best DE in the AFCN. That makes it awfully tough to argue they had the same impact.
____________________________________________________________
Posts: 15,116
Threads: 221
Reputation:
147378
Joined: May 2015
(10-14-2023, 11:27 AM)TheLeonardLeap Wrote: Yes, and at his peak Geno was....
1. 1st Team All-Pro
2. The 29th best player in the league according to his peers
3. The best player in the league at his position
...Hendrickson is none of those.
I already said Geno is better at his position, although I feel we're picking nits, here. Geno was 2nd at his position and Hendrickson is arguably top 5 at his. At LEAST top 8.
Again, I'm strictly talking impact, here. Atkins wasn't the best at his position. He was always behind Aaron Donald. Not the point, though.
We just have to agree to disagree and move on. If there's a huge gap between Atkins and someone with 28 sacks in 36 games and who also balled out in the playoffs, then I don't see it. Maybe a small gap, but a huge one? On impact? Nah, man.
We're fanboying a guy if we say that.
The training, nutrition, medicine, fitness, playbooks and rules evolve. The athlete does not.
Posts: 19,737
Threads: 634
Reputation:
85957
Joined: Oct 2016
1
Posts: 1,952
Threads: 10
Reputation:
10578
Joined: Apr 2020
(10-16-2023, 04:56 PM)Shake n Blake Wrote: ...Again, I'm strictly talking impact, here. Atkins wasn't the best at his position. He was always behind Aaron Donald. Not the point, though...
Atkins was either all pro 1st or 2nd team in 2011, 2012 and 2015. Aaron Donald made his first all pro team in 2015. Atkins was drafted a few years before Donald so you cant say Atkins was never the best at his position when the two player's careers dont completely line up. Atkins was being named 1st team all pro while Donald was still in college so you cant say he wasnt the best at his position when Donald wasnt even in the league to compare Atkins to.
Posts: 15,116
Threads: 221
Reputation:
147378
Joined: May 2015
(10-16-2023, 10:25 PM)007BengalsFan Wrote: Atkins was either all pro 1st or 2nd team in 2011, 2012 and 2015. Aaron Donald made his first all pro team in 2015. Atkins was drafted a few years before Donald so you cant say Atkins was never the best at his position when the two player's careers dont completely line up. Atkins was being named 1st team all pro while Donald was still in college so you cant say he wasnt the best at his position when Donald wasnt even in the league to compare Atkins to.
I knew someone would step in and point out that their careers didn't entirely overlap. 
Let's just leave Donald out of this and say that Atkins "only" won 1st team all-pro twice, so how many times was he the consensus #1 DT? Not often.
That said, you're not debating my overall point, here. There's not a huge gap between 2nd at your position and 5th at your position (apparently, PFF has Hendrickson 3rd this year, thanks, Pistons), and it was easier for Atkins to get recognition for that type of impact at the DT spot than it is for a DE to get recognition.
Imo, the best argument for Atkins is that getting pressure up the middle is better than edge pressure. I just don't see a huge gap in impact overall.
Also, as much as I loved Geno (he was my favorite defensive player, probably ever), he did have a lot of stretches where he went invisible. I don't feel that way about Hendrickson.
The training, nutrition, medicine, fitness, playbooks and rules evolve. The athlete does not.
Posts: 28,174
Threads: 352
Reputation:
242352
Joined: Aug 2016
Kay does make a pretty strong case.
1
Posts: 5,611
Threads: 36
Reputation:
36352
Joined: May 2015
Location: Vancouver, WA
I said it on twitter a few weeks ago, and I'll say it again here. Trey is the best free agent signing in Bengals history.
You can always trust an dishonest man to be dishonest. Honestly, it's the honest ones you have to look out for.
"Winning makes believers of us all"-Paul Brown
Posts: 38,919
Threads: 922
Reputation:
132480
Joined: May 2015
(12-14-2023, 01:56 AM)Bengal Dude Wrote: I said it on twitter a few weeks ago, and I'll say it again here. Trey is the best free agent signing in Bengals history.
I'm kinda partial to Bobbie Williams.
WTS, love Trey and he make take my #1 one day
Posts: 15,116
Threads: 221
Reputation:
147378
Joined: May 2015
The guy just keeps balling. He's sacked the QB in 11 of 13 games this year. He has 13.5 sacks with 4 games left.
The training, nutrition, medicine, fitness, playbooks and rules evolve. The athlete does not.
1
Posts: 17,290
Threads: 239
Reputation:
137105
Joined: Oct 2015
(12-14-2023, 04:52 AM)Shake n Blake Wrote: The guy just keeps balling. He's sacked the QB in 11 of 13 games this year. He has 13.5 sacks with 4 games left.
Absolutely a great pass rusher. Likely the second best pass rusher I have ever seen in a Bengals uniform (Atkins). I do think we need to talk about him playing a bit fewer snaps, though, for the sake of the run defense.
____________________________________________________________
Posts: 2,679
Threads: 232
Reputation:
7704
Joined: Jul 2015
Dunlap's run defense was trash his last season and half with us he cost us a couple of games in Taylor's first season due to his trash run defense that's why he got demoted and ultimately released the off the field stuff didn't help either. At the time I was willing to take Dunlap's side but when the rest of the starting defense started calling Dunlap out and taking the coaching staff side. Tre can take over a game I cant recall Dunlap ever taking over a game
Posts: 36,529
Threads: 49
Reputation:
236350
Joined: May 2015
Location: Star Valley, Wyoming
(12-14-2023, 01:44 AM)Nicomo Cosca Wrote:
Kay does make a pretty strong case.
Love Kay and love Trey THE MANIAC!!!
Posts: 1,183
Threads: 2
Reputation:
7376
Joined: Sep 2015
Trey is probably my favorite all time FA signing. I loved it then, love it now, and I hope to see him retire a Bengal. He is one of the best 4-3 ends out there and I was happy to see him sign that one year extension recently.
My ONLY gripe is that he plays exclusively at RE. Wish he was versatile enough to swap sides as needed or move inside (the man is built like an oak tree, why can't that translate to 3T on 3rd and longs?!).
Love me some Blackout Trey!
Posts: 36,529
Threads: 49
Reputation:
236350
Joined: May 2015
Location: Star Valley, Wyoming
(12-14-2023, 03:08 PM)The D.O.Z. Wrote: Trey is probably my favorite all time FA signing. I loved it then, love it now, and I hope to see him retire a Bengal. He is one of the best 4-3 ends out there and I was happy to see him sign that one year extension recently.
My ONLY gripe is that he plays exclusively at RE. Wish he was versatile enough to swap sides as needed or move inside (the man is built like an oak tree, why can't that translate to 3T on 3rd and longs?!).
Love me some Blackout Trey!
That is the gripe with Trey not being to play all over the line. He just likes to abuse the LT it seems. 
|
![[Image: 9c9oza.jpg]](https://i.imgflip.com/9c9oza.jpg)
![[Image: 4CV0TeR.png]](https://i.imgur.com/4CV0TeR.png)
